2011 Countdown: Shaun Burgoyne

Started by ossie85, September 08, 2010, 07:54:15 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Will you select him?

Locked in
2 (6.1%)
On the short list
8 (24.2%)
touch and go
9 (27.3%)
Unlikely
11 (33.3%)
No.
3 (9.1%)

Total Members Voted: 4

Alex7089

True. Hodge won't be cheap though he would have to act as an Ablett or Swan 0_o
I could pass on Ablett but with Swan would you get the Dane for consistency or Hodge...Because he doesn't play for Collingwood :P
I personally want Buddy over Cyril but if you didn't get Hodge or Burgoyne you could get Delicious. So is he (Rioli) better value than Hodge/Burgoyne?

MajorLazer

That is the problem that is going through my head except for me it's "Is Buddy better than Hodge?"

I'm getting Cyril and if he's MPP, I'm getting Buddy as well. I'll also be getting both Swan and Hodge.

oodmutler

I will be going with Swan and Hodge, trying to work out who i can squeeze in between them and my three starting rookies.

Buddy is a lock for me. Havn't really considered Junior Boy yet. If he was assured to play a more midfield dominate role, then i would consider him for sure.

Alex7089

So ML you are saying Hodge, Buddy, Cyril & maybe Burgoyne :O
Swan is a , but again, fair price? I don't really how he can improve on last season.. :-\

Barlow 21

Quote from: hawka26 on January 03, 2011, 01:04:13 AM
at this stage he has turned to a lock
Just my thinking! Wanting him last year so this is my chance.

Hawka

i have the same hawks problem i want burgoyne,bailey,cyril,buddy and puopolo

Barlow 21

Quote from: hawka26 on January 03, 2011, 11:12:13 AM
i have the same hawks problem i want burgoyne,bailey,cyril,buddy and puopolo
No Hodge?

nas

Hodge would be an upgrade target. Is for me ATM

pyronerd

Quote from: naste on January 03, 2011, 12:00:45 PM
Hodge would be an upgrade target. Is for me ATM
+1 wiould be a good one after hawks 2nd bye

Hawka

hodge is an upgrade target after the hawkers last bye in rnd 16

Barlow 21

Quote from: hawka26 on January 03, 2011, 12:28:01 PM
hodge is an upgrade target after the hawkers last bye in rnd 16
Okay I see. That is a good idea as some rookies may have peaked around then.

Alex7089

Ah good point Hawka.
We pass on Hodge now and get Burgoyne + Buddy/Cyril and then upgrade to Hodge after the bye. Clever.

Hodge should come down as well :) .

Still have the Buddy or Cyril problem though.
Unless Cyril is MPP in which case we could pass on Burgoyne and get Cyril + Buddy. Unless you wnt Burgoyne more than you want Cyril.

Hawka

i may go with both even if cyril is just a fwd becos cyril will get middie time and buddy has had his first uninteprupted pre season and due to hale will get more middie time

Alex7089

Yeah I suppose but we would still only be able to pick them in the forward line and the bye would be an issue even with one very early (so the rookies we start with should still be playing) and 3 emergencies. Then with Hodge Burgoyne it would be a very bad week for your SC D:

Knowall

Not going to consider Burgoyne is getting old and has injury problems.  But i really like him as a player and he did play well last year so could be a good buy for some