Round 20 Ruckmen Decisions (Resource)

[Master Q]

Well, Today I've been looking around the DT and SC P&T boards and I've noticed that there have been a lot of people wondering which Ruckmen they should bring in for Sandi or who to upgrade to. I've created a list with stats on most Ruckmen, so It would be easier to choose which one you need.

Mummy- Scored Mid-80's in his last 2 games, has scored 3 tons this year, has scored below 60 4 times, missed 2 games, and has a BE of 76. Average, 80.7. $329,900 Against: Fremantle

Cox- Scored 86 and 79 in his last 2 games, has scored 4 tons this year, has scored below 60 3 times, missed 0 game, and has a BE of 72. Average, 83.1. Price, $313,300. Against: Port Adelaide

McIntosh- Scored 128 and 91 in his last 2 games, has scored 2 tons this year, has scored below 60 3 times, missed 2 games, has a BE of 40. Average, 81.5. Price, $342,400. Against: St.Kilda

Ryder- Scored 68 and 90 in his last 2 games, has scored 5 tons this year, has scored below 60 3 times, missed 0 games, has a BE of 81. Average, 86.0. Price, $316,600. Against: Collingwood

Jolly- Scored 81 and 73 in his last 2 games, has scored 3 tons this year, has scored below 60 2 times, missed 0 games, has a BE of 105. Average, 77.8. Price, $343,500. Against: Essendon

Jamar- Scored 47 and 112 in his last 2 games, has scored 3 tons this year, has scored below 60 6 times, missed 0 games, has a BE of 75. Average, 73.1. Price, $310,200. Against: Hawthorn


Looking at this list, who do you think is the best ruckmen to choose?

Extra Notes: I'm not in need for a Ruckmen, this is for other coaches who need help. If there are any more players you need me to add, just ask.

[RiOtChEsS]

^ nice work Q

[Master Q]

^ nice work Q

Thanks, Took about 10 Minutes  :)

[Blueboys]

I have the week off so hope his back next week or I'll pull the trigger, like the options you listed Q. Is it worth starting a poll to see who people will be going for or are we all jumping the gun if his back next week  :-\

Also can you add Jamar and Jolly also good ruck options atm...

[ossie85]

Darren Jolly looks pretty solid right now

[Master Q]

Ok, I'll Jamar and Jolly soon. Then I'll add a Poll when I finished. But should the poll be who is the best option or who are they going?

[valkorum]

Best option

[Master Q]

Best option

Ok Thanks, I'm updating the list know as well.

[Blueboys]

Yeah best option....

[Master Q]

Updated with added poll.

Just noticed Jamar has no consistency.

[valkorum]

Cox is my choice.  Price vs what he can output is a good mix IMO.  Plus this week is his 200th game so he may try and take the game on himself to try and get the win for the team

[DG]

Good work Q. Id get cox...

[Master Q]

On Paper Cox and Ryder are pretty much even. Ryder looks better, but he's playing Collingwood and Cox is playing Port so that evens it up. A lot of people have talking up Mummy lately including me, but on paper he is worse then Cox and Ryder to me.

[thatguy]

this week only surely Mummy would have to be ok against a freo minus sandi!

[Master Q]

Comon People, let's get voting? Only 4 votes in so far, 3 of them go to Cox.