Is 3 cats in the midfield to much?

[lions(L)]

I'm thinking of bringing in Bartel this week for Martin,
but i already have ablett & selwood in my midfield,
would 3 geelong players in my midfield be to many?

[roo boys!]

Possibly with the resting stage coming up, although if they lose this week they shouldn't rest people because they have a chance of dropping down to 4th.

[CFC 1979]

jimmy's definately carrying an injury in his elbow

but thats what makes this game so good - risk taking and learning from it

good luck

[lions(L)]

hmmm.
apart from jimmy,
i'm also thinking shane tuck or kade simpson in for martin,
then upgrade fyfe to n.riewoldt.
i have 254k in the bank with 2 trades.

[Hawka]

At lkeast they wont rest them all at once

[cmpurrfect]

I am in a similar position, but don't have the cash that you do.

Other good Martin upgrade options for you would be:
Mitchell
Gibbs

Goodluck

[Flame]

No it isn't, but I'd be wary of Jimmy with the elbow injury!!

[roo boys!]

At lkeast they wont rest them all at once

they could do what Saints did last year.

[lions(L)]

At lkeast they wont rest them all at once

they could do what Saints did last year.

that cost me the premiership,
i had 6 sainters in my team last year.

[SCADDICT]

No, if anything 3 is not enough!

[phil17680]

I have had all 3 for a while. I started with gaz and bartel. Then selwoon dropped to 500k so I had to snap him up. The only problem is that all 3 haven't fired together in a game yet from memory. But you always get around 300 points from the 3

[Bosh]

3 is great when they are all in good form, ATM Selwood is the only one there in great form, Ablett alright and Bartel not great. I would steer clear of Bartel.

[RiOtChEsS]

id say no with the weagles in round 22 plenty of pill for everyone

[Alex7089]

I would say at this stage it probably is, if you already had the three in there it would be fine but Jimmy is playing hurt at the moment and if Geelong get over the line against the Dogies this week then they will most likely rest him for finals.

Along with a few others  :-\

[sunny_side_down]

I am in a similar position, but don't have the cash that you do.

Other good Martin upgrade options for you would be:
Mitchell
Gibbs

Goodluck

yeah i like mitchell too, i think he could prove a bit of an x factor for some finalists. can score the pitiful 60 70 odd but has those massive 140s every month or so too... query on sammy is the disposal efficiency, continually burns the ball which hurts his SC