Best and Fairest!

[Boomz]

Jamar, over Hmac, Cox, Hille etc. ???
I suppose he could, as I said I haven't really been paying much attention :P

Easily over those 3 his main contenders would be Mummy & Jolly. Doubt there will be a 2nd ruck in the 22 though.

[Fletch74]

Jamar, over Hmac, Cox, Hille etc. ???
I suppose he could, as I said I haven't really been paying much attention :P

Easily over those 3 his main contenders would be Mummy & Jolly. Doubt there will be a 2nd ruck in the 22 though.

+1

[Master Q]

Not Jolly. But Mummy.

[Alex7089]

Jolly has been good, albeit inconsistent, but played well...

[ossie85]

1. Sandi
2. Jamar
3. Jolly
4. Mummy

for me.

Jolly scores a lot more goals than Mummy which puts him over the line IMO.

[Master Q]

Where'd Kruze be, I'm just curious. 6, 7?

[ossie85]

For this year?

5. McIntosh
6. Hudson
7. Ryder
8. Cox
9. Kreuzer
10. Hille

IMHO

[Alex7089]

Hmmm, do you think Ryder has really been better than Hille?

[ossie85]

Only on number of games played really, Hille's missed a lot. This is All-Aus rankings for me.

[Alex7089]

Ok then. From a supporters point of view I see Hille as a much more important player although I obviously like it better when they both play ;D

[Master Q]

For this year?

5. McIntosh
6. Hudson
7. Ryder
8. Cox
9. Kreuzer
10. Hille

IMHO

Hudson.

If we forget about Stats for a second I think it would be like this:

1. Sandi
2. Cox
3. Hille
4. Jolly
5. Ryder
6. Hmac
7. Jamar
8. Krooze
9. Mummy
10. Hudson

Controversial Picks:

Hille:A few years ago people Ranked Hille as the best ruckmen, he hasn't been in the best of form. When he plays to potential he earns No.3

Jolly: Anyone remember him at Sydney? Yep, he's dominant.

Jamar: No.7 is a good spot I think, only had one stand out year.

Hudson: Don't ever notice him, doesn't break open games.

[Justin Bieber]

1. Sandi
2. Jamar
3. Jolly
4. Mummy
5. McIntosh
6. Hudson
7. Ryder
8. Cox
9. Kreuzer
10. Hille

Have to agree with that. Maybe Ryder ahead of Hudson and that would be how I set it up this year.

For Melbourne's B&F, Got to be Green hands down. Next would be Frawley. The kid has stepped it up this year and really shut down his opponents this year. Jamar a worthy 3rd place.

[Alex7089]

Jamar has been VERY good this year!

I think Cox has been better than Ryder/Hudson.
To me Hudson doesn't seem to have much ingluence on games and Ryder has been very inconsistent.

[Master Q]

That list is great for this year except for Hudson. If you did it for potential and career then you would have to change it completely.

[CFC 1979]

disposals YTD

Total Kicks Aaron Davey 287   Kicks Per Game Aaron Davey 15.11 
Total Handballs Cameron Bruce 258   Handballs Per Game Cameron Bruce 14.33 
Total Disposals Cameron Bruce 423   Disposals Per Game Brent Moloney 23.75 
Total Marks Brad Green 134   Marks Per Game Brad Green 7.05 
Total Goals Brad Green 47   Goals Per Game Brad Green 2.47 
Total Hitouts Mark Jamar 544   Hitouts Per Game Mark Jamar 28.63