Main Menu

Crazy ruck situation

Started by SCADDICT, August 01, 2010, 08:32:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

SCADDICT

Carlton have too many ruckmen!

dylsta05


ossie85


rooattack

Why are they chasing David Hale???

At least we will get abetter deal than from the Gold Coast

SCADDICT

In all seriousness though, whats gonna happen with this situation. I though big Sauce Jacobs was set to become the number one ruck in Kreuzers absence, and then the number two when Kreuzer is back. But now Warnock is number one ruck ?  ???

dylsta05

very weird ADDICT but only one of them are good 

Cruiseon

Agreed dylsta and he'll end up being a forward.

I think once Carlton get Hale, Steven King, Charman, Skipper and perhaps Laycock their team balance should be about right. It is important they stick to their strategy and ensure no ruckman recruited shows any signs of being remotely above average.  ;)


bunyip

Quote from: Cruiseon on August 03, 2010, 06:42:03 PM
Agreed dylsta and he'll end up being a forward.

I think once Carlton get Hale, Steven King, Charman, Skipper and perhaps Laycock their team balance should be about right. It is important they stick to their strategy and ensure no ruckman recruited shows any signs of being remotely above average.  ;)
Geeez cruis, Geelong should employ you as their list consultant. You have a very innovative approach. :)

Cruiseon

Bunyip, if Geelong followed my or even better carlton's list management we'd have the flag wrapped up. Alas that is not the case.

bunyip

You don't have to have a team full of first draft picks do you. Geelongs, and probably Collingwoods scouts need a pat on the back. From memory, and I stand corrected, Chappy was 30 something.

Cruiseon


bunyip


ossie85

Quote from: bunyip on August 03, 2010, 11:18:36 PM
Quote from: Cruiseon on August 03, 2010, 11:06:37 PM

Swan at 58!
You're kidding :o

Nope, in that same year Sam Mitchell at 36, Leigh Montagna 39, Gary Ablett jnr at 40 (what a joke father son!!).....

Cruiseon


Yep Swan at 58, Brian Lake at 71 meanwhile our old friends at Carlton took Justin Davies with their first pick. Quality drafting.

A bit like taking Bryce Squibbs at no.1 ahead of Joel Selwood and Jack Riewoldt. Lucky they picked up Shaun Hampson with their second pick.

bunyip

Didn't you get Cloke and Heater with the father son rule?