Is Scotland the 4th best back?

[Footy God]

See title. Obviously Goddard, Hodge and Lake take the top 3 spots, would Scotland be the next best back to have for the last 5 games?

[laney21]

hodge definitely above him but yeah he is a gun

[Holz]

your joking right?
obviously Goddard and HODGE are the top 2 guys

[plugz19]

yeah good call, him gilbert and fisher are a much of a muchness

[Uncle]

James Kelly seriously slipping under the radar.

[vman33]

alot of people would say scotland after gilbert's 39 last week
i would say for the whole year gilbert then scotland but the two are hard to seperate

[elephants]

i think kelly would be my only cat next year with the tag likely to be shifted between bartel (:( ), selwood, chappy and corey

[CFC 1979]

James Kelly seriously slipping under the radar.

x2

have totally overlooked him. having a great year

[Footy God]

Trading out Maguire so don't care about the other 17 rounds. Just want to know who you think will average higher for the last 5 games? Fisher/Gilbert may be rested I reckon so thinking Scotland.

Already have Kelly btw.

[Bazinga]

Trading out Maguire so don't care about the other 17 rounds. Just want to know who you think will average higher for the last 5 games? Fisher/Gilbert may be rested I reckon so thinking Scotland.

Already have Kelly btw.

If you are considering a trade for the last 5 rounds, don't forget to consider Jarrod Harbrow . He is in great form and with coach Eade experimenting with Brian Lake up forward, there is a potential for Harbrow to keep pumping out big scores.

[Footy God]

Having a rethink again.

Could go Waters-Goddard.


Depends, what is the best combo?

Waters + Scotland + Ball
Goddard + Ball + Maguire
Montagna + Waters + Maguire

[Fletch74]

James Kelly seriously slipping under the radar.

x 3 Am so glad that I had him from the start and persisted with him despite his late withdrawls.

[thatguy]

i think kelly would be my only cat next year with the tag likely to be shifted between bartel (:( ), selwood, chappy and corey

i would remove corey from this list. isnt damaging enough by foot to be tagged

[McRooster]

Scotland 4th, then throw a blanket over Kelly, Duffield, Gilbert, Malceski, Fisher and Goodwin.

[browny_wce]

should have gone kelly over shaw preseason