The Most Underated & Overated Players In AFL Thread.

[Windigo]

That's the burning question.

I'd say Boyd. Got any others that deserve more recognition??

[jvalles]

Ryan Griffen deserves more recognition.

I'd say Pendles is underrated because the popularity is with Swan and Didak.

[elephants]

you would have to say simpson is under rated BUT he seems to be unable to cope with a tag :(

in my opinion the Q stick is over rated. the comentators get really excited when he has the ball but he isnt as good as he used to be :(

pendles is under rated but does get taged from time to time and ryan griffen dominated freo :)

[McRooster]

Swallow from the roos definately under the radar.

[Windigo]

Yeah, if you were looking for quality Pendles is great. Where Swan, (I'm not taking anything away from him) but some of his kicks are just kicks into open space, and some of them seem to be absolute floaters.  :P

[Flame]

you would have to say simpson is under rated BUT he seems to be unable to cope with a tag :(

in my opinion the Q stick is over rated. the comentators get really excited when he has the ball but he isnt as good as he used to be :(

pendles is under rated but does get taged from time to time and ryan griffen dominated freo :)

Which Q do you mean??? ;D

[McRooster]

Master Lynch ???

[ossie85]

Cameron Bruce is the best player in the AFL not to make an All-Aus team.

[Master Q]

What's all this talk about me! I heard me name!

[Flame]

Your over rated Q!!

[MiGZ]

most underrated - brad green, daniel cross, chance bateman, jordan russell.

most overrated - tom hawkins, kurt tippett, mark mcveigh, andrew welsh, dom cassissi, des hedland, quinten lynch, jarrad mcveigh, justin sherman, daniel connors (he is either the most selfish or just plain stupid decision maker ive seen).

[browny_wce]

most underrated - brad green, daniel cross, chance bateman, jordan russell.

most overrated - tom hawkins, kurt tippett, mark mcveigh, andrew welsh, dom cassissi, des hedland, quinten lynch, jarrad mcveigh, justin sherman, daniel connors (he is either the most selfish or just plain stupid decision maker ive seen).

agree with those in bold
add nicnat to that bunch, he averages 1 mark per game  :-\
lynch is useless, cant believe we have someone like callum wilson as an emg every week when hes kicking 5+ goals a game in the WAFL and lych misses goals from 30m out

[HillHero13]

Nic Nat for sure too overrated

Cross underrated...

Gumbelton overrated..

[jvalles]

Nic Nat for sure too overrated

Cross underrated...

Gumbelton overrated..

i didn't know gumby was rated anything, lol!

[elephants]

yeah haha dunno about gumby :P

nic nat will be a great player. he is only 19 and as we all know bigmen take longer to develop. he will be a gun. (you heard it from me). yes tom hawkins very over rated. any of these under rated players worth a look for dt next year?