Risking It All

[Windigo]

From my previous post about Sylvia, the general consensus was no and maybe.

I need your final opinions on whether to trade him in, his all i can afford at $340 k.

As you know my choice will take into account your thoughts, but I'll make the decision in the end.  ;) I think he would go alright. Looks fit.  :-\

[browny_wce]

who u trading for and whos already in ur forwards?

[Windigo]

Okay,

Fwds (Current)

J.Brown
Goodes
Gia
Pavlich
Posdiadly
Rockliff
Fyfe

Watts (e)
P.Davis

I'm trading P.Davis to Sylvia.

[GinoGod]

what about ROK or Brennan

[Paddy13]

yeah get okeefe

[Windigo]

I have Rok in the mids.

How much is Brennan in DT?

[browny_wce]

nah bugger off brennan...useless one trick pony

target sylvia (or maybe higgins-cheaper)
but i wuld probly trade out fyfe, as i and out with injuries
davis more of a lock in CHB everyweek for the crows n a great emg option, plus gives u the mpp

[DevilsReject]

While Fyfe is good bench cover, Davis and Watts would do the job as well. You could always trade Fyfe instead and from what I can tell you would just about be able to get anyone.

[Windigo]

I would have $429,900 to spend on a FWD, if i trade Fyfe.

I don't want the Riewoldts. So don't suggest them,  ;)

Maybe Didak or Harvey, and pocket the cash for finals.

[McRooster]

nah bugger off brennan...useless one trick pony

target sylvia (or maybe higgins-cheaper)
but i wuld probly trade out fyfe, as i and out with injuries
davis more of a lock in CHB everyweek for the crows n a great emg option, plus gives u the mpp

+1

Bock still not named in Crows squad makes Davis all the more worth keeping.

[Windigo]

Didak or Harvey!!

[browny_wce]

culd didak get rested?
harvs looks great with JZ and anthony out of the team

[Windigo]

Didak looks more consistent, but yeah he may get rested.

Harvey for more unique? I think didak has more selections. Not sure. ???

[valkorum]

Dale Thomas could be an option as well if you are after a unique - averaging 2 more DT than Didak and 5 more than Harvey.  Although Harvey's last 3 games average is higher

Average
Didak     93.93
Thomas  95.67
Harvey   90.47

3R Average
Didak     91.33
Thomas  91.33
Harvey   99.33

[Windigo]

Thomas...... :-\

Never ever considered him as an option.....Still don't.  :P

Sorry, the stats don't lie. But I'm leaning towards Harvey.