Buddy Franklin

Started by The General, July 10, 2010, 09:52:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

The General

Looked on Cats vs Hawks score + chat and he got MRP icon on him.
Is he in doubt 4 next week, im saying this coz i don't have cover 4 him.

hawk_88

They'll look at it. It looked far worst at the ground than it did on replay. I don't think his hand actually touched the head and it had minimal impact. I've been wrong before but I don't think anything will come of it. Guess we will find out Monday evening.

The General

Yeah I know i was at the game as well but I didn't see much in it so I didn't really worry.

McRooster

Nothing to worry about.

Blueboys

buddy  bloody franklin!  ;D

gruby

will get one week, and with his poor record, will get 2.

hawk_88

Quote from: gruby on July 11, 2010, 12:15:49 AM
will get one week, and with his poor record, will get 2.

The only charge that might see him miss a match is worth 125 demerits. He has 25 carry-over points which takes it to 150. Then 20% loading is applied which would take it to 180, not enough for 2 weeks. However I'm pretty sure that would mean it would still be a week with an early plea.

MalteserMan

I dont see how he can even get 1 week?

The contact was not intentional, replay clearly show that he got him cross the body and that the contact slipped up.

If he gets a week for this, they are out to get him... especially if Anthony (collingwood) gets off for what Franklin got suspended for 3 times....

Fletch74

Quote from: MalteserMan on July 11, 2010, 08:19:36 AM
I dont see how he can even get 1 week?

The contact was not intentional, replay clearly show that he got him cross the body and that the contact slipped up.

If he gets a week for this, they are out to get him... especially if Anthony (collingwood) gets off for what Franklin got suspended for 3 times....
+1

hawk_88

Quote from: MalteserMan on July 11, 2010, 08:19:36 AM
I dont see how he can even get 1 week?

The contact was not intentional, replay clearly show that he got him cross the body and that the contact slipped up.

If he gets a week for this, they are out to get him... especially if Anthony (collingwood) gets off for what Franklin got suspended for 3 times....

I agree, but if they were out to get him that is the charge he would get.

carpsi

It was reckless.
His bad record will not help.
Probably a week I feel

kazam

i think he'll be ok. maybe 93 demerit reprimand, with 25 carry over points he'll get a week, early plea will put him under.. not sure how the 93point reprimands work though. it wasn't a huge coathanger/strike. he just sort of went to push him a bit and his arm slipped. if he goes then daisy should go for his soft jumper punch imo.

hawk_88

Quote from: kazam on July 11, 2010, 12:40:16 PM
i think he'll be ok. maybe 93 demerit reprimand, with 25 carry over points he'll get a week, early plea will put him under.. not sure how the 93point reprimands work though. it wasn't a huge coathanger/strike. he just sort of went to push him a bit and his arm slipped. if he goes then daisy should go for his soft jumper punch imo.

As soft as Daisy's jumper punch was, it was intentional so in effect it should be worst that Franklin's.

ando_10

they will throw it out.

Torress

for football sake franklin should not get done! if he gets rubbed out for that football is coming to a new low.