montagna chapman boyd or hayes?

Started by Gava, July 08, 2010, 10:35:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

which option, please poll

chapman
7 (26.9%)
montagna
12 (46.2%)
boyd
6 (23.1%)
hayes
1 (3.8%)

Total Members Voted: 5

Gava

barlow to montagna chapman boyd or hayes?

midfield: ablett swan bartel barlow pendlebury sellwood (gysberts shuey)

chapman has his dual position ability so i would have cover with strong fwd bench if he goes down.

elxam

if have trades to cover for chappy or a very strong bench, go the bald knight

valkorum

Chapman is who I would choose.  The MPP may be the difference at the pointy end of the league season.

Encoñado

Quote from: elxam on July 08, 2010, 11:25:46 PM
if have trades to cover for chappy or a very strong bench, go the bald knight

+1

Gava

only thing is though, i have 5 geelong players already, including 3 mids. so if they happen to have a rest week then im up the pooper

woozie10

Up the pooper? You'll be there when you face me in the GF anyway...
I say Boyd, if you look at his last 4 scores, he's pretty hard to go past. Especially with your Geelong players, even though I have five now as well...

daniel lucanus

im going chappy for his dual positioning
ive got no midfield bench cover but 2 playing benchies in the forwards so if chappy is rested i can easily put pav/okeefe/goodes/dids into the mids for him and play ballantyne of p. davis in the forwards

Flame

Chappy in great form but I went for Tags instead of the bald Knight..DPP is helpful though

Davoo

chapman = injury prone and could be rested.