Two Geelong Superstars

Started by Jim Bean, July 08, 2010, 09:02:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which player to trade for Barlow?

Chapman (MPP & highscores)
Ablett (proven gun)
Montagna (not keen)
Boyd (Nahhhh)

Jim Bean

Ok. Chapman and Ablett. Which will be the better asset for the rest of a season?

Ablett has the higher average (only just), but Chapman is more reliable.

Missed games should be around the same. Ablett will be rested, and Chapman will be rested if his hamstrings flare-up.

Also, Chapman is a FWD/MID (MPP) and I have multiple FWD/MIDs in my forward line (Higgins, ROK, Brennan.. etc). So, I could cover any 0s easily...

Vote in poll.

McRooster

#1
Where's the poll?

I vote Ablett :)

...because of Geelong team structure, especially with Corey back. They are programmed to protect and set for GAJ.
Chappy has to work harder for his points, might take a toll on those hammies!

Flame


Jim Bean

The Poll is now here  :)

Ablett... hmm...

Holz

if you are using the DPP than chapman if not ablett

Plastic Boy

I've gone Ablett.  This guy was so expensive at the start of the year, now I have a chance to sideways trade so I'm all over it.

With Corey back, Ottens in, and Hawkins, SJ and Rooke on the comeback, the cats will be at full strength and Ablett will be collecting even more ball, if possible.

With crutial games coming up against Hawks, Pies and Dogs, he'll thrive in those games and all play high possession style.

Chapman just is a headache, every time he kicks it I think his hammies are going to go 'TWANG'.

Jim Bean

Hmm... I'm starting to worry about Chappy's hamstrings.

Montagna or Ablett?

St Kilda does have an easy ride home...

Flame

I was thinking of Chappy but will play it straight and get Montags..