Nic Nat 11'

[Master Q]

Anybody considering him? 3rd year, could show more consistency and will get more time in the Ruck.

Thoughts?

(At this stage, I've already planned my rucks, and they don't include Nic Nat, so don't go at me)

[Justin Bieber]

Not for me :). Don't like too much inconsistency.

[valkorum]

Most likely a no from me.  I didnt jump on him this year and I am glad I ddint.

[CFC 1979]

he is going to be number 1 ruck i think possibly taking over sometime next year
if he can learn more of the pre-season could be one to watch

[elephants]

yeah i like him as a player bu not the best dream teamer :(

[browny_wce]

yeah i like him as a player bu not the best dream teamer :(

to tell u the truth mate, i dont actually rate him as a player, doesnt work anywhere near as hard enuf (but then again none of the eagles do)

i mite consider goldstien next year...ruckman who likes a few goals and tries to take big marks in the forward 50, also jolly next year will be 10x better, suited to the pies, a premiership with them? possibly less and less time for fraser who culd be traded?? (cant seem to get a game)

[elephants]

if fraser goes then i will lock in jolly. if he stays it will be the old sandi/ryder combo for me.

i think nic nat needs time. lets face it he is playing in a pretty abysmal team at times and he cant do it all on his own. he has shown a bit, but i agree west coast need a good solid talking to from me the inspirational team counciller :)

[hardnut]

can't see too much changing unless Cox is traded. Avoid NicNat - decent young player in a poor team, maybe 2012/13

[rocca]

no way.. 2011 for me will be sandi and goldstein or hille..
you need ruckmen which can find the ball around the ground as well as win hitouts and take contested marks.. that isn't nic nat

[ossie85]

Mummy?

[bundyboy]

ok - everyone lock in Sandi

mummie ??  he has starred this year - can he keep it up? probably yes.

ryder - again has been great, with and without Hille - so definate maybe

hille - got back to terrific form after injury, but then injured again...will he be able to maintain fitness and stay on the park??  Big question

Ottens - coming good again  - but just misses too many games thoughout the season...probably not

tippet - crap start to year, but starting to show what he can do - plus MPP - definate maybe

jolly - yep, starting to show the form he had at Sydney, likes a goal and should be better for the run this year - another definate maybe

goldie - big surprise packet this year, and looks to be on the up...like him too.

gee, it's going to be tough choice for that 2nd ruck spot...

[McRooster]

Sandi locked.
Tippett may get re-elevated off my shower list.
If Lynch and co. get moved out of West Coast in an end of season cleanout, I might get Nic for his fwd scoring potential :-\

[roo boys!]

Nah, I wouldn't get him.

[Master Q]

Nah, I wouldn't get him.

[Justin Bieber]

Mumford might be good. But need to see him score this well when Seaby is also in the lineup.