Trade Help :D

[dcmagadia21]

DEF: Goddard, Hodge, Waters, Duffield, Harbrow, Shaw, Davis
         Maguire, Heath

MID: Swan, Montagna, Bartel, Barlow, Watson, ROK
         Gysberts, Shuey

RUC: Sandilands, Cox
         Warnock, Roughead

FWD: Pavlich, Giansiracusa, Hall, Podsiadly, Franklin, Hitchcock, Henderson
          Chapman, Brown

4 trades left and $49,400 in the bank

1st

Option 1 - Straight swap Maguire to Carrazzo or another MPP back (suggest who)

Option 2 - Straight swap Brown to Harvey or another MPP forward or forward/mid (suggest who)

2nd

Option 1 - Do the trade either for next round or the round after

Option 2 - Trade in the latter stages of the 22 rounds

Option 3 - Don't trade at all

So if possible, make two choices please  ;D thanks

[Prospector_1]

How does mpp Carrazzo (or other) in back help if there's no mpp B/M in the mids?

I see that apart from this, you have a good mpp set up, I think. It looks like what you need is a B/M in the mids - get Carrazzo (or other) there. You already have a swing for F/M by mpp.


Therefore, first choice appears to be option 2. At least then you can swap more mpp forwards and mids.

As to when - 4 trades remaining suggests as late as possible.


If you can find the right mpp mid for B/M, maybe sooner.

Or did I miss something obvious?

[roo boys!]

Whether to trade out Maguire or Brown.......

Maguire should be back in 1-2 weeks, whereas there are rumours that Brown could miss another 4. How true these rumours are, I'm not sure but just wait until we hear from Vossy or Brown as to when he will be back. Brown said that he should be back soon but then the rumour spread that he could be out for more. If he is coming back soon then I would hold, I have a feeling when he I 100% that be will be pulling out 120's so he is worth holding. If he turns out to be out for more then you should probably trade him, possibly for Nick Reiwolt who should be back in 1-2. But if you can't afford this trade then Harvey would be a good option. The other thing is I would prefer to have someone like Harvey in my team rather than Carrazzo because he has been tagging a lot more recently. His DT scores have still been quite solid but they are not what I would expect from someone of his premium status. You can't start both Hitchcock and Henderson and have two premiums sitting on the bench so hopefully Chappy will be back this week and then Brown can be either traded out or come back soon.

As for when......

Pretty much as mentioned above, it all depends on when Brown will come back. If he is out for more than 2 weeks than the sooner you trade the better, but it also depends on whether you are going for leauge win or overall ranking. If you are going for a leauge win then you should hold some trades for leauge finals, you would want to have 3 left for then IMO, but if you are going for overall ranking, the sooner you upgrade the better.

[dcmagadia21]

How does mpp Carrazzo (or other) in back help if there's no mpp B/M in the mids?

I see that apart from this, you have a good mpp set up, I think. It looks like what you need is a B/M in the mids - get Carrazzo (or other) there. You already have a swing for F/M by mpp.


Therefore, first choice appears to be option 2. At least then you can swap more mpp forwards and mids.

As to when - 4 trades remaining suggests as late as possible.


If you can find the right mpp mid for B/M, maybe sooner.

Or did I miss something obvious?

I meant MPP as Mid Priced Player.

[Prospector_1]

OK, I guess that was obvious! ::)

[dcmagadia21]

so what should i do prospector?

[Master Q]

OK, I guess that was obvious! ::)

You seem to pick up all m0nty's mistakes but not these ones ;D

Take a blow for the mean time, wait for Maguire then Sub him on for Davis.

[Prospector_1]

so what should i do prospector?

Wait. Only 4 trades, maybe no donuts. See who comes back soonest & fittest.

[dcmagadia21]

if chappy plays this week, you should i start for brown?

hitchcock vs. freo at subi

or

henderson vs. essendon at aami

[dcmagadia21]

OK, I guess that was obvious! ::)

You seem to pick up all m0nty's mistakes but not these ones ;D

Take a blow for the mean time, wait for Maguire then Sub him on for Davis.

i'll do that in the mean time. davis looks like he'll play out the season.

[McRooster]

if chappy plays this week, you should i start for brown?

hitchcock vs. freo at subi

or

henderson vs. essendon at aami

Hitchcock and Henderson start, Brown and Chappy won't play!

[dcmagadia21]

Whether to trade out Maguire or Brown.......

Maguire should be back in 1-2 weeks, whereas there are rumours that Brown could miss another 4. How true these rumours are, I'm not sure but just wait until we hear from Vossy or Brown as to when he will be back. Brown said that he should be back soon but then the rumour spread that he could be out for more. If he is coming back soon then I would hold, I have a feeling when he I 100% that be will be pulling out 120's so he is worth holding. If he turns out to be out for more then you should probably trade him, possibly for Nick Reiwolt who should be back in 1-2. But if you can't afford this trade then Harvey would be a good option. The other thing is I would prefer to have someone like Harvey in my team rather than Carrazzo because he has been tagging a lot more recently. His DT scores have still been quite solid but they are not what I would expect from someone of his premium status. You can't start both Hitchcock and Henderson and have two premiums sitting on the bench so hopefully Chappy will be back this week and then Brown can be either traded out or come back soon.

As for when......

Pretty much as mentioned above, it all depends on when Brown will come back. If he is out for more than 2 weeks than the sooner you trade the better, but it also depends on whether you are going for leauge win or overall ranking. If you are going for a leauge win then you should hold some trades for league finals, you would want to have 3 left for then IMO, but if you are going for overall ranking, the sooner you upgrade the better.

I'm looking to win 2 of my 3 leagues (currently winning both of them. one of my leagues the top 2 are both undefeated and I'm only leading by percentage and the other league I am winning by percentage) and win my school comp (currently #3 in my school). But I also want my ranking to be above 10,000 (currently 12,735 of 313,837). That higher ranking would be nice  ;D

[bundyboy]

ok - some decent options depending on when brown & goose come back...

BUT  only 4 trades left !!

hold out as far as possible - still far too many weeks to go to burn more trades now unless you absolutely ABSOLUTELY must