kelly, carrazzo or duffield

Started by sledgey7, June 16, 2010, 08:07:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

which backman

carrazzo
4 (13.8%)
duffield
11 (37.9%)
kelly
14 (48.3%)

Total Members Voted: 4

sledgey7

still not sure if i'll do the trade but not knowing if taylor hunt (my maguire cover) will play next week is kind of forcing my hand to trade out maguire.if i do. which of these three do the FF public think would be the best option?

carrazzo
duffield
james kelly

browny_wce

go kelly man, unique, no one else will snap him up
everyone going for duffy or already have carrazzo

sledgey7

i like the idea. the only thing that worries me a little is that geelong are so good that you can't gaurantee that kelly will always be in the best 22. also carrrazzo a little cheaper. could use the extra cash to upgrade higgins.
although i could just wait until jbrown comes back and turn higgins into him and gain some cash.

valkorum

I would be quite comfortable that Kelly is in their best 22

browny_wce

yeh if hes not starting in the mids/wing he'll be half back or at the very least a benchie, he is a very good player and deff in their 22

chrisuzz

could get Q's latest "Hop on Him" player, Grimes

woozie10

Kelly is a gun and jump on him.

sledgey7

convinved.
wlecome to the sledgers james kelly

morgan1132

wouldnt get carrazzo, he seams to be playing a tagging role more often and impacts his scoring ability.  Duffield or Kelly, flip a coin, similar stats