AFL missing Step 1

[Master Q]

If they really wanted to tackle NRL, why don't they start a State of Origin between Victoria and South Australia? Possibly between Split Round or maybe ever a rest round with a Monday Night Game? Or they could make a Tri-State Cup, Vic v SA v WA? Thoughts?

[Justin Bieber]

Don't they usually have the Whitten's Legends game around this time?

Victoria would dominate if it was split up into states.

[CFC 1979]

been done Q

we won't see state of origin again me thinks

[ossie85]

If they really wanted to tackle NRL, why don't they start a State of Origin between Victoria and South Australia? Possibly between Split Round or maybe ever a rest round with a Monday Night Game? Or they could make a Tri-State Cup, Vic v SA v WA? Thoughts?

Last time it happened regularly, the players didn't want to play and nobody showed up.

My ideal is this:

Group A: Victoria City, Victoria Country, SA, WA
Group B: Qld, NSW/ACT, Tas, NT

[Master Q]

Don't they usually have the Whitten's Legends game around this time?

Victoria would dominate if it was split up into states.

That's Not Serious, Peter Heller or whatever his name is ::)

been done Q

we won't see state of origin again me thinks

That was one off

Last time it happened regularly, the players didn't want to play and nobody showed up.

My ideal is this:

Group A: Victoria City, Victoria Country, SA, WA
Group B: Qld, NSW/ACT, Tas, NT

That Was Last Time. I like Group A but not B.

[ossie85]

Last time it happened regularly, the players didn't want to play and nobody showed up.

My ideal is this:

Group A: Victoria City, Victoria Country, SA, WA
Group B: Qld, NSW/ACT, Tas, NT

That Was Last Time. I like Group A but not B.

No it wasn't, last time it was Victoria, SA, WA and the 'Allies'

[reesbr]

afl have nearly already killed NRL by taking some of their best players

[Justin Bieber]

It's not serious but its the closest thing there is to State of Origin in the AFL ;D.

[Master Q]

Last time it happened regularly, the players didn't want to play and nobody showed up.

My ideal is this:

Group A: Victoria City, Victoria Country, SA, WA
Group B: Qld, NSW/ACT, Tas, NT

That Was Last Time. I like Group A but not B.

No it wasn't, last time it was Victoria, SA, WA and the 'Allies'

Ossie I wasn't talking about that, It was about the players...

[ossie85]

In that case, the players would be less likely to want to play it regularly now - with an increased work load

[Master Q]

In that case, the players would be less likely to want to play it regularly now - with an increased work load

Hence a Week rest, mate read all of it.

[ossie85]

A weeks rest wouldn't stop injuries during the games, clubs would hate it. Look at Josh Fraser, injured himself in the Victoria v Dream Team match and hasn't gotten fit since.

[Master Q]

A weeks rest wouldn't stop injuries during the games, clubs would hate it. Look at Josh Fraser, injured himself in the Victoria v Dream Team match and hasn't gotten fit since.

Hmmm Ossie. If Josh Fraser Played. Did Fevola Play? What about Lance Franklin?

[ossie85]

You're correct Q, not every player got injured in the match! What's your point??

I really want state of origin, just saying it's unlikely to ever happen!

[Master Q]

You're correct Q, not every player got injured in the match! What's your point??

I really want state of origin, just saying it's unlikely to ever happen!

My Point Is They All Played.