Kornes, Gibbs & Selwood

[username]

quite keen on all three. atm selwood is in, but still unsure.

other mids are: Ablett, Judd, T. Tuck, Rich + (Beams, Robinson)

thanks.

[username]

btw, i have c. cornes in the backline if that matters.

[CrowsFan]

i've got the same dilemma as you do. i can't decide which two of the three i should have. at the moment i have selwood and gibbs, just because i think they will both continue to improve, whereas i think kane has hit his limit

[username]

yeah selwood and gibbs should improve, but does kane cornes have a higher ceiling? he is 26 years old. very durable (played 22 games in 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008). Port should bounce back after a poor 2008. He is good value (his 2008 average of 93.7 is actually below his career average of 100.1). I also read somewhere that he will benefit from brother chads return.

i dunno. was gibbs breakout year 2008. will he plateau in 2009. is he overpriced (averaged 1120 over the final 9 rounds of 2008, but his season average was 93).

Geelong, Carlton, Port...probably the strongest midfields in the competition...are there enough points to go around?

Will selwood go up in value? i know many teams have him, but do people intend on keeping him or upgrading?

i dunno.

[username]

dropped selwood, but the poll is telling me to drop gibbs...i think.

[Ziebelling]

yeah selwood and gibbs should improve, but does kane cornes have a higher ceiling? he is 26 years old. very durable (played 22 games in 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008). Port should bounce back after a poor 2008. He is good value (his 2008 average of 93.7 is actually below his career average of 100.1). I also read somewhere that he will benefit from brother chads return.

i dunno. was gibbs breakout year 2008. will he plateau in 2009. is he overpriced (averaged 1120 over the final 9 rounds of 2008, but his season average was 93).

Geelong, Carlton, Port...probably the strongest midfields in the competition...are there enough points to go around?

Will selwood go up in value? i know many teams have him, but do people intend on keeping him or upgrading?

i dunno.

Stop being so negative and get Gibbs into your team. That kids a star.