Trade Help... please

[cledus32]

I am looking to make a trade this week got 2 options of people to bring in, but need help.
option 1: Chapman (gun) & Gilbee (rollercoaster)
Option 2: Gilbert/Russel (consistant) & Thomas/Goodes/Franklin/Waite

Need Help whether to go with option 1. If option 2, which combo do you reckon?

[CuStArDaRm]

if you can get chappy.....GET CHAPPY  :P

[Spite]

Can't go chappy and carrazo?

[cledus32]

Back Line: Hodge, Carrazzo, Enright, Duffield, Waters, Maguire
Fwd Line: Pav, Didak, Brown, ROK, Gia, Hall, Pods

Will be upgrading Maguire and Gia. Can't afford Goddard (i wish) I can, but then wont have enough money to use on the gia upgrade.

[jvalles]

Stick with Gia dude, and go for Goddard.

[JStapo21]

What about upgrading Hall? Paul Roos has already said he's gonna miss games and theres always the chance of a suspension. Plus Gia is only in a bad patch of form he'll come good eventually. How about straight swap Hall>Sylvia   Maguire>Goddard. Sorry if thats a bad idea, but this is my first year playing Dream Team.

[jvalles]

What about upgrading Hall? Paul Roos has already said he's gonna miss games and theres always the chance of a suspension. Plus Gia is only in a bad patch of form he'll come good eventually. How about straight swap Hall>Sylvia   Maguire>Goddard. Sorry if thats a bad idea, but this is my first year playing Dream Team.

How would Paul Roos know Hall will miss games?!?

[JStapo21]

Roos said that he was going to rest Hall a few times during the season to ensure his body holds up for his 10th or something season.

[jvalles]

Roos said that he was going to rest Hall a few times during the season to ensure his body holds up for his 10th or something season.

Paul Roos coaches Sydney...Hall plays for Rodney Eade of the Bulldogs?!?!

[JStapo21]

ohh sorry brain fade. I meant Eade.

[jvalles]

ohh sorry brain fade. I meant Eade.

Haha, for a second there I thought I was just being incredibly stupid.

[JStapo21]

Nope, I'm the stupid one :D