10 Trades....Time to stop trading?? or just 2 more....

Started by BGK, May 13, 2010, 09:11:04 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

BGK

I have 10 trades left and im pretty happy with my team. I have a few underperforming players, but they are going ok at the moment.

Defenders:   L Hodge, N Malceski, C Enright, J Grimes, S Hurn, B Waters,
                    M Maguire (B Nason, J Davis)

Mids:            D Swan, M Barlow, J Watson, J Bartel, B Gibbs, M Boyd
                    (T Scully, R Bastinac)

Rucks:          A, Sandilands, H Macintosh (R Warnock, M Lobbe)

Forwards:    J Brown, R O'keefe, E Betts, A Didak, J Podsiadly,
                    R Murphy, C Rioli (S Gumbleton, N Fyfe)

I only want to make 2 trades in the next 6 weeks. Except for LTI's. So my question is should I fix up Murphy or Rioli or wait for a while?

Harvey_29

youve jumped the gun. no way u will last the season out with waters and maguire 6 and 7 in ur backs etc

luketown

no ablett, chappy or goddard..? are you happy with that?

BGK

Ablett....No but I will pick him up next year to start with.

Chappy and Goddard Yes im fine with not having either of them at this point. Im not a fan of Goddard this year. I feel with him going forward in some games he can be too inconsistent. I dont like Chappy at all. His hammys are to much of a worry.

SCADDICT

Quote from: Harvey_29 on May 13, 2010, 09:34:21 AM
youve jumped the gun. no way u will last the season out with waters and maguire 6 and 7 in ur backs etc

there not looking that bad! you can't upgrade everyone. You upgrade who is the most urgent spud and those two certainly wouldnt be on the top of my list.

freezer

Get Murphy out! You are worried about Chappy's hammys...Murphy must be next in line in the 'who's the most injured queue.'

BGK

Yeah I know. He is gone this week. Probably going to get Goodes

milnesmarvels

ur an idiot mate, if u think chappys hammys are gone well then why is he in top 5 of supercoach and goodard wherever he plays is gunna have his up and down games but is still gunna score over 90 nad more then likely 100 +. Also chappy has played 33 outta 42 games so he has missed 9 games. ablett has played 35 outta 45 games. in the past few seasons yet yr worried about chapmans hammies, u obvsiosuly dont have a clue in the world, thats just 1 mans opinion

BGK

Your a dick. If you look at chappy its WHEN his hammies happen not the fact they do. With Goddard there are other cheaper options that are going to get you the similar scores. With Ablett that is exactly why I picked Swan over him. But your going to come out and say im an idiot for wishing he was in my team. Man some people on here are White Goodmans. But thats just one mans opinion......

BGK

Just another question...why did you choose to say 33 out of 42. Looking at the FF site he has played 42 out of a possible 52. He has missed 5 games in each of the last 2 seasons. In his 10 years of playing AFL he has only managed to play 22 3 times. Does this not say injury prone to you. Everyone talks about. But maybe you cant read. Plus Ablett has missed 8 games in the last 2 and a half years. Maybe you cant count either. Sorry if this seems harsh but its just one man opinion.

thesupercoachfob

Calm down mate, when you put your team up you should be open to criticism. And the milnesmarvels has a point, Gablett has had freakish scores this year 150, 171, 203 , and Chapman has also had very high scores as well. Gablett is a must have because he will win you league games. Also no Pav is a worry, Pav is a superstar nothing less than a hundred since round 2 and has had only one game below a hundred. Altogether a solid team, and i think 6 trades is not enough for over 10 rounds.