Hargrave + 150k or DUFFMAN!

[ossie85]

Joel Macdonald, the experiment failed. Can't have a backmen like you getting dropped on form. So, off you go!

So, the question?

Trade for Hargrave, or spend the extra cash on DUFFMAN?

Other options willl be noted...

The best response gets a free cookie*


* - there is no cookie

[reesbr]

lol Hargrave

[Najoman_86]

Cookie sounded enticing...quite disappointed ;)

Ditto above - Hargrave the way to go!

[Samm79]

the Hargraves option has more value in it, especially if you have a spot for the $150K in the coming weeks.

[ossie85]

Hmmm, but is Hargrave really a premium? Only averaged over 80 once in his career. DUFFMAN a similar story, but has been in far better form....

[ossie85]

Oh great. I did the Hargrave trade. FML

[sunny_side_down]

Oh great. I did the Hargrave trade. FML

ended up with a 60
is never going to be the premium now that gilbee is back fit and firing, everyone forgets that he was carrying an injury thru last year and he is taking points off hargrave now

[Resch]

Hargrave made his B/E (1 under) and still could pick up.

Gilbee has a B/E of 124 and is starting to look like a nice pick up in a few weeks.

[Alex7089]

Ouch, would've said Duffman had I seen it... Mainly because I think Hargrave will go back to what he was scoring before last year this year. I said this in another forum, wasn't convinced after one good game, and after all- how good was it?

[Justin Bieber]

Ouch, would've said Duffman had I seen it... Mainly because I think Hargrave will go back to what he was scoring before last year this year. I said this in another forum, wasn't convinced after one good game, and after all- how good was it?

What he said. a breakout year at 29 is something that needs to be looked at. If he wasn't a fantasy scorer his entire career and breakouts so late, don't think he is one.

Would of said Duffy unless you really needed the cash. He did have a breakout year but is younger and in his prime. His running game is suited to sc as he can kick it into the 50 when splitting the middle.

[Bluke]

Yep, Freo defence is the best young defence in the comp.. Duffman and Broughton anyday. 

Got the Duff in DT and Broughton in SC

[alman]

Went Hooker to Duffield, reckon he's the better option with his new midfield role and in form.

[ossie85]

You are all geniuses! Duff man spudded it up! Never doubted for an instant lol

[Alex7089]

Duffy will win out in the long term. Although he will lose a fair bit of money. WIll definitely look at picking him up in 2 weeks now. Maybe for Goose? Or Waters if I can ride the storm that is his bad form.

[alman]

Went Hooker to Duffield, reckon he's the better option with his new midfield role and in form.

:'( my first big (short-term) trade screw up!

Hooker the ton, Duffield 50..