Too many Cat midfielders?

[gerco]

I'm looking to get in Joel Selwood this week, but as I already have Bartel and Ablett, I'm thinking that 3 Geelong mids in one team is too many.

(I'll be looking to trade out either Luke "1-2 weeks" Shuey or Ryan Bastinac for him if that's helpful at all)

Any thoughts?

(5 trades used, 500k in the bank)

[GinoGod]

wouldnt trade luke ball just yet. i think there is better options than selwood

[valkorum]

I didnt have a prob with Ablett, Bartle and Selwood in my side last year.  So far I have Ablett and Bartel in my team this year.

[Justin Bieber]

wouldnt trade luke ball just yet. i think there is better options than selwood

He was talking about schuey.

Seems a decent upgrade as you are getting in another premium. Selwood is quite cheap and think 3 in 1 position is too much but those 3 seem to score well most weeks. Could work out but if you don't want 3 cats, maybe look elsewhere. Finals times is when some players start to get rested.

[GinoGod]

cornes or hayes are good options if u got that extra cash

[brodman_18]

I have heard a few people now say there are better options than sellwood. If so who and are they better value?

[Prospector_1]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,13008.0.html

[Flame]

I didnt have a prob with Ablett, Bartle and Selwood in my side last year.  So far I have Ablett and Bartel in my team this year.

Agree..put Chapman in there 2..

[GinoGod]

wouldnt you think more of a spread is better. havent seen once this year ablett bartel and selwood all get over 100 in the 1 game. correct me if im wrong

[gerco]

wouldnt you think more of a spread is better. havent seen once this year ablett bartel and selwood all get over 100 in the 1 game. correct me if im wrong

First game of the year against Essendon, Bartel got 114, Ablett 129 and Selwood 107.

[GinoGod]

is that the only 1?

[gerco]

Yeah, Selwood has only the 2 tons this year, one against Essendon and one against Richmond on Sunday when Ablett didn't play.

[GinoGod]

selwood was a slow starter for me last year but then came good....could do the same this year

[bundyboy]

can't have too many cat midfie4lders !!! ;D ;D

[bundyboy]

can't have enough cat midfielders !!! ;D ;D ;D