Cox vs Hille vs H-Mac

[Robert Harvey 35]

which ruckman will be the best for the rest of the season? worried that cox may get injured or be rested due to wce not likley for finals and the emergence of naitanui.

[MissPiesFF]

Cos is your best bet in regards to those three. Even when WCE are on the bottom COX manages to score big time. Look at last year. WCE was sh*t and he pulled up over 100+ per round. You just can not go past premiums no matter who they play for win or lose.

[BGK]

I think Cox is certainly back in form, but with another dominant ruckman around in Nic Nat I dont think he will consistently get you those big scores like he used to.

Hille is still too risky IMO. Could get suspended or go down injured any time.

H Mac looks the best value to me. He is a bit cheaper and will still get you good scores pretty much every week.

[Master Q]

Got HMAC, but Cox I think.

[Boomz]

Cox is the one to go for out of those 3...

[yorgis]

cox or sandi is the way to go, but if u want cash why not think about jamar[his ave is 86 which is better than ryder,leuenberger,nicnat,clarke and jolly] he's only295k

[yorgis]

sorry mis typed should be 76

[elephants]

i have hille and i always thought hille to cox but with coxxys groins i will keep hille for the season as he can really step it up IMO

[CFC 1979]

big C

[bundyboy]

if cash is no problem, then cox.

if you want to save $40k, then hmac, as he is still likely to score consistently well.

i worry about hille....

[Flame]

Normally I'd say Big Cox but you can't go past Hmac for consistency...He is safer but big cox could deliver more???? I have the same dilemma??

[numberwang]

Dont know why people stress about Hille, he had the one jnjury and before that he was a gun. Looks like he's back his best and I won't be trading him out. HMAC looks a good option...

I do worry about cox's longevity...excuse the pun.

[elxam]

Cox

[valkorum]

I think Cox is certainly back in form, but with another dominant ruckman around in Nic Nat I dont think he will consistently get you those big scores like he used to.

I dont consider NicNat to be a dominant ruckman.  He is a burst player who can break open a game in patches (which he didnt do against Freo :P)

I think Cox is the choice here.  Consistant and gets a lot of ball around the ground.

[elxam]

agree