Silvagni for which def under 325k??

Started by craftcoat, May 05, 2010, 04:04:09 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Silvagni to:

Hargrave
15 (48.4%)
Bauer
4 (12.9%)
Malceski
12 (38.7%)

Total Members Voted: 2

elephants

yeah i have malceki myself and he has really bolstered my backline get him and lock him :)

browny_wce

malceski boat has sailed mate. shudve got him at 220k
hargrave is looking cheapish, tho not sure
bower is an outsider i recon

elxam


craftcoat


with the bastinac to howlett downgrade i can actually afford up to 382k for silvagni, it was just that i wanted to get a hargrave/bauer/malceski etc to save cash for future mid upgrades but after thinking it over i think it's best if i use all my available funds and get a top, reliable premium that will definitely bolster my backline; pretty confident i'll be getting Heath Scotland: he's got a solid 6 yr average and lowest score so far has been 80, plus i like that he's semi unique compared to his teammate in carrazzo.
- Could get grimes or wait a week for H. Shaw but i like Scotland's durability & lack of getting tagged better...
-backline would be: duffield,enright,hodge,gram,scotland,harbrow,waters (hunt,nason)

thoughts guys??? cheers  ::)  thanks for the feedback so far!

elxam

I like that idea.
Scotland is certainly unique and ever consistent and reliable.

Andrew

Out of those listed, Hargrave because he's cheaper than Malceski... but what about Chad Cornes? Breakeven of 28, $286k, had a great Showdown game.

craftcoat

yeah cheers mate,  I think this move suits my team structure better and makes this double trade seem really worth it whereas with hargrave, it just feels way to hit or miss. It's been a long day behind the DT office but i think i've finally unravelled this one haha

@Andrew- Chad looks on his way out to me, i'll keep him on the watchlist but he'll need a fair few scores like that to be even considered for mine. cheers though

numberwang

BTW its Bower.

I would stay away from Chad, too injury prone and def on the down from the peak of his career. I think Bower could be an option. Hargrave really doesnt do it for me, and everyone is jumping on. Seems like a sinking ship. Malceski is a better option than hargrave.

elxam

if you didn't pick Eski in your original team you might have missed the boat