3 holes need filling

Started by Queenslander, March 21, 2009, 03:54:38 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Of these

Hase/Malceski/Petrie
0 (0%)
Hase/Drummond/Simmonds
1 (50%)
Hase/Fisher/H-Mac
0 (0%)
Selwood/Malceski/H-Mac
8 (400%)
Harding/Hodge/Simmonds
2 (100%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Queenslander

I Have 1 position left in the defs, mids, and rucks. these guys fit the bill. anyone have other ideas?

nas


Cool9


ando10


Queenslander

sorry guys i have goddard, its meant to be fisher

ando10

oh k go gilbee selwood h-mac

jazz

yeah gilbee over fisher, gilbee can score big

Queenslander

i've got gilbee, goddard, ccornes, johncock, raines, hill, petrenko, cheney in defence.

Alex7089

haha Queenslander I have an Identical backline reserves ansd all with only 1 exception (houlihan not Johncock)

yeahsup


troy87

I'm suprised everyone is pointing out players cause when i saw the heading i have 3 holes that need filliing that was not my intial thoughts lol.

ando10

hahahaha so did i but then i opend it

Marcus

Going in with the mindset that the ruck will stay untraded for the rest of the season. (Assuming you've already picked Cox)
The second option is out because over the course of the season you'd have to trade both Hasleby and Drummond.
Simmonds is not a SC scorer at all and represents no value this year (unlike last year when he was over priced) so we're left with:
Selwood/Malceski/H-Mac
Hasleby/Fisher/H-Mac
Hasleby/Malceski/Petrie
The third option is ruled out for mine because the value H-Mac presents is too good to pass on over paying that amount for Petrie. Also H-Mac will probably be out of the ruck now (= more points [potentially]) with Hale/Petrie combo Laidley seems to love.
So it's Selwood/Malceski VS Hasleby/Fisher
Selwood wins me over because I think he will finish the season costing 600+k. Fisher will probably hover at his 550k price tag.
Hasleby and Malceski probably will both have to be traded and therefore we're looking from a monetary perspective. Both cost similarly and will probably peak to be sold about 450k.

DobbosDevils

Selwood was the winner for me too. I see no value in H-Mac or Malceski, but Selwood is the bonus!