Which rookie defender - Ashton Hams, Phil Davis and Simon White?

[scullgove]

I am trying to choose between Ashton Hams, Phil Davis and Simon White.
Who has a more secure job?

[Flame]

I'm going Hams this week!!

[valkorum]

Hams or Davis appear to have the better job security.  I think Davis just because of the LONG injury list at the Crows and the fact he was a high draft pick (I think number 10)

[Flame]

Yeah..Davis is also mpp

[valkorum]

Yeah..Davis is also mpp

yeh but how many players are B/F multi position? 

Davis
McPhee
Grundy
Gwilt
McPharlin
Waite
Hurley

[thornz23]

there are about 2 threads the same as this but again.. :P u dnt want white because once thornton, waite and bower come back he'll be out. then out of hamsn davis both r good options i think maybe hams will have better job security immediately but in the long run if adelaide keeps playing the way they are they are bound to start seeing what their young guys have got so davis will probly get a pretty secure spot in the team. but just preti much choose the one that gets named this week. if both get named then both r good options

[Flame]

Yeah..Davis is also mpp

yeh but how many players are B/F multi position? 

Davis
McPhee
Grundy
Gwilt
McPharlin
Waite
Hurley

Ha..true not many

[valkorum]

Hams
AVG = 58
BE = -58

Davis
AVG = 70
BE = -70

Wow - has spun out is that their break evens are the same as their averages (except in the negative)

[scullgove]

Hams is a mature age player (23yo), where Davis is 19yo ...

[Flame]

Weird!! I like the mature age rookies this year

[thornz23]

haha thats a pretty ridiculous coincidence valk :P
and i didnt even realise hams was mature age lol that means he must be as good as barlow.... right....?? :P

[valkorum]

Nah, no-one is as good as Barlow

[thornz23]

haha damn it! thought maybe we could have every mature age rookie this year becoming that amazing :P

[valkorum]

Although it would be nice to have another rookie priced player who could become a keeper

[scullgove]

It would seem that White is also mature age (21yo) ... also coming from WA...