Riewoldt to ...

Started by BGK, April 10, 2010, 11:52:01 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

What to do?

Chappy
20 (14.6%)
ROK
21 (15.3%)
McGlynn
4 (2.9%)
Byrnes
1 (0.7%)
Brennan
21 (15.3%)
Houlihan
2 (1.5%)
Murphy
0 (0%)
Ballantyne
0 (0%)
Hall
0 (0%)
Rockliff
5 (3.6%)
Gumby
2 (1.5%)
Hitchcock
1 (0.7%)
Goodes
6 (4.4%)
Betts
1 (0.7%)
Higgins
3 (2.2%)
Dangerfield
1 (0.7%)
Didak
2 (1.5%)
Davis
1 (0.7%)
Rioli
14 (10.2%)
Franklin
0 (0%)
Pav
21 (15.3%)
Higgins
3 (2.2%)
or what?
8 (5.8%)

Total Members Voted: 12

Voting closed: April 17, 2010, 12:25:54 PM

Master Q

Quote from: GinoGod on April 10, 2010, 03:38:08 PM
6 weeks is a bit over the top.....wont miss that long
Yeh, probably 3-4.

wipz

Depends how long he is out for but anything over 5 weeks and I will go to Sylvia if in form.

Hoggy

im pretty sure if he tore it off the bone he wouldnt have hobbled off like he did... anyone who has tore it like that will agree with me, most painful thing ever. hopefulloy only 4 weeks on the sidelines

jak_crow

ok

grade one tear 1-2 weeks resting it up

grade 2 tear anywhere from 2-4 max 5 weeks

but to be honest if you had to gauge how bad the severity looked and the fact that he couldn't walk on it at all (compare to cousins last year, hopped off) most prob a grade 3. so we could be looking at a minimum of 6 weeks up to 10 depending :(

if it is of the bone then we will be looking at surgery. depends what muscle he has torn off as there are 3. but 3 month minimum

scary stuff as im sure alot of us have him, guess will see in the upcoming few days :(

Master Q

Quote from: Hoggy on April 11, 2010, 03:41:01 AM
im pretty sure if he tore it off the bone he wouldnt have hobbled off like he did... anyone who has tore it like that will agree with me, most painful thing ever. hopefulloy only 4 weeks on the sidelines
You can only hope if your not going to trade him out :P

browny_wce

"i dodged that bullet by not getting him at all  "

u serious?? mustve been posting some avg scores up forward without him

ELLsendon


craftcoat


anybody that didn't start with Riewoldt in their team this year is actually mentally retarted, no offence...but seriously bragging about NOT having riewoldt, hmmmm.....

Justin Bieber

Quote from: browny_wce on April 11, 2010, 04:47:15 AM
"i dodged that bullet by not getting him at all  "

u serious?? mustve been posting some avg scores up forward without him
well yeah. got gray missing :'(. but after trades i should get both brown and Roo up there if not i'll get 2 other premiums. i plan ahead.

So apparently I'm mentally retarded ::) alsifhregnusxvh :P

boost

Unfortunately i made a last minute decision to put him as captain.

:(

boost

I will wait and see what the verdict is before I trade him out.

Didn't look promising though.

Justin Bieber

unlucky boost. on the bright side, you weren't the only to do it ;)

ossie85


The bullet wound is critical.

ossie85



Happy I didn't trade Harvey for Brown now! Riewoldt for Brown swap looks good

stevemac

potentially the decision that makes or breaks a side in 2010...
who are you going to replace St. Nick with (if any)?...

top 15 ranked forwards after 2 rounds
1. BROWN, Jonathan
2. RIEWOLDT, Nick
3. O'KEEFE, Ryan
4. BRENNAN, Jared
5. BYRNES, Shannon
6. CHAPMAN, Paul
7. MURPHY, Robert
8. HIGGINS, Shaun
9. THOMAS, Dale
10. EBERT, Brett
11. PETTERD, Ricky
12. HAHN, Mitch
13. GOODES, Adam
14. HOULIHAN, Ryan
15. BALLANTYNE, Hayden

bargains?
24. PAVLICH, Matthew
27. JOHNSON, Steve
29. DIDAK, Alan
35. GIANSIRACUSA, Daniel