50 reasons why Collingwood is better than Carlton.

[ossie85]

Bit of a pattern there!

[CFC 1979]

ok bit of grand final history between us

grand finals Coll V Carl   = 6

wins

Coll = 1 ( 1910 )
Carlton = 5 ( 1915, 1938, 1970,1979, 1981. )

Just trivial or Trivia

[jezzablue]

ok bit of grand final history between us

grand finals Coll V Carl   = 6

wins

Coll = 1 ( 1910 )
Carlton = 5 ( 1915, 1938, 1970,1979, 1981. )

Just trivial or Trivia

kinda kills the point of this thread...well done  ;)

[elephants]

Well played CFC ;D

[PowerBug]

The only way you can judge who is better is by who's beaten teh other the most, or who has beaten the other in certain games, or in recent times.


Not sure what the overall is, but the recent is 7/4 Pies i think and as CFC said the GF is 5/1 Blues.


I think they are both good teams. Compared to my team. :P

[elephants]

Collingwood has Dayne Beams... Therefore Collingwood > Carlton.

[ossie85]

Tanking, a heap of #1 picks, salary cap trickery with Chris Judd, and still not contenders

[T Dog]

Have you seen or met a Carlton supporter? ...Oh please... :o

[elephants]

Collingwood can beat an undermanned Eagles side in Melbourne ;)

[nostradamus]

let's bring some logic to the discussion

.......Carlton supporters have more teeth

[ossie85]

How about this for a reason?

After 3 rounds Carlton were premiership favourites, and Collingwood were written off. 9 wins a row for Collingwood seem them top, and Carlton have slipped out of the 8

[elephants]

I've backed Collingwood throughout this thread bit this one is against you blokes, sorry.

Carlton's away kit > Any of Collingwoods jumpers.

[ossie85]

I've backed Collingwood throughout this thread bit this one is against you blokes, sorry.

Carlton's away kit > Any of Collingwoods jumpers.

That light-blue nonsense? I'm surprised a team whose song contains the words "Navy blues" would give in so easy....

[elephants]

I've backed Collingwood throughout this thread bit this one is against you blokes, sorry.

Carlton's away kit > Any of Collingwoods jumpers.

That light-blue nonsense? I'm surprised a team whose song contains the words "Navy blues" would give in so easy....

Hahah I see your point but I kinda like it :P

[Cruiseon]

Although it's only June it's probably worth mentioning that one team is top of the ladder and the other one, well ..... when I look, seems not to be located in the eight. Maybe it's a typo?