Main Menu

Hawks ruck dep.

Started by Master Q, April 07, 2010, 07:42:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Master Q

Shows how much their rucks struggle, Hawks had 22 hitouts in total while Geelong had 46.

valkorum

Renouf against Ottens is hardly fair :P

Although Renouf did score 74/53 (DT/SC) and Ottens scored 89/122

Master Q

Remember a guy called Mark Blake?

ossie85


Renouf is a premiership ruckmen, should quit his whinging :)

Master Q

Quote from: ossie85 on April 07, 2010, 09:22:05 AM

Renouf is a premiership ruckmen, should quit his whinging :)
Wonder what m0nty will say about that ;D

Justin Bieber

i saw hodge and peterson going up for hitouts. really struggling in that department.

need to start recruiting for the future ;)

Big_Cox14

If the Hawks want to be serious about challenging for a premiership this year they need another ruckman to help out Renouf as well as bulking up their backline who looked shaky against an ordinary Geelong forward line. If the backline is as shaky this week then the bullies will run riot.

Master Q

Quote from: Big_Cox14 on April 08, 2010, 08:49:34 AM
If the Hawks want to be serious about challenging for a premiership this year they need another ruckman to help out Renouf as well as bulking up their backline who looked shaky against an ordinary Geelong forward line. If the backline is as shaky this week then the bullies will run riot.
I agree, You think there next draft pick will be a ruckmen?

Justin Bieber

Quote from: Master Q on April 08, 2010, 08:52:29 AM
Quote from: Big_Cox14 on April 08, 2010, 08:49:34 AM
If the Hawks want to be serious about challenging for a premiership this year they need another ruckman to help out Renouf as well as bulking up their backline who looked shaky against an ordinary Geelong forward line. If the backline is as shaky this week then the bullies will run riot.
I agree, You think there next draft pick will be a ruckmen?
They never use their first pick for a ruckman. i would expect them to draft a guy half way through and treat him as a project player.

I would rather see them trade for a good ruckman like collingwood did with jolly.

Master Q

Quote from: Hellopplz on April 08, 2010, 08:58:53 AM
Quote from: Master Q on April 08, 2010, 08:52:29 AM
Quote from: Big_Cox14 on April 08, 2010, 08:49:34 AM
If the Hawks want to be serious about challenging for a premiership this year they need another ruckman to help out Renouf as well as bulking up their backline who looked shaky against an ordinary Geelong forward line. If the backline is as shaky this week then the bullies will run riot.
I agree, You think there next draft pick will be a ruckmen?
They never use their first pick for a ruckman. i would expect them to draft a guy half way through and treat him as a project player.

I would rather see them trade for a good ruckman like collingwood did with jolly.
That is only a good resource for a few years, where if you had a rookie you could groom him even as 2nd ruck as nothing wrong is renouf.

Justin Bieber

Quote from: Master Q on April 08, 2010, 09:12:11 AM
Quote from: Hellopplz on April 08, 2010, 08:58:53 AM
Quote from: Master Q on April 08, 2010, 08:52:29 AM
Quote from: Big_Cox14 on April 08, 2010, 08:49:34 AM
If the Hawks want to be serious about challenging for a premiership this year they need another ruckman to help out Renouf as well as bulking up their backline who looked shaky against an ordinary Geelong forward line. If the backline is as shaky this week then the bullies will run riot.
I agree, You think there next draft pick will be a ruckmen?
They never use their first pick for a ruckman. i would expect them to draft a guy half way through and treat him as a project player.

I would rather see them trade for a good ruckman like collingwood did with jolly.
That is only a good resource for a few years, where if you had a rookie you could groom him even as 2nd ruck as nothing wrong is renouf.
Don't think renouf has what it takes to play as a number 1 ruckman against quality ruckman.

Master Q

Everyone has different ways of being a coach i guess...

CFC 1979

i think the hawks need to look at the coaching department

against geelong the kid was stuffed, followed ottens off for a break but was sent back on.

Why couldn't Buddy or Roughy be sent into ruck to help out ?

That move lost Hawks the game without a doubt

haooyy

Can't question Renouf's effort though, was at the game on the weekend and saw him dislocate his finger on the wing, got it popped back, then presented and took a mark in the opposite back pocket a minute later.

Anyone know how Grimley and Lowden are progressing? One of those guys should be tried out sometime during the year. We cant afford to have players like Hodgey going up for ruck, we need him at the fall of the ball

Justin Bieber

bailey touted highly down at the hawks. should be fit mid year but he needs to get his body straight.