SC 09 RATE THIS

[DT ELITE]

I generally prefer DT but here is my SC anyway. Ive tried to pick as many price improvers as possible whilst keeping the team balanced. What would you give the team out of 10 and why?

BACKS:
A, McPhee
L, Hodge
C, Cornes
R, Houlihan
N, Malceski
J, Adcock
S, Fisher

CENTRES:
K, Cornes
B, Cousins
P, Hasleby
D, Kerr
S, Higgins
D, Rich

RUCKS:
D, Cox (c)
H, McIntosh

FORWARDS:
M, Pavlich
P, Chapman
J, Brown
N, Brown (Richmond)
J, Porplyzia
S, Sidebottom
C, Yarran

BENCH
J, Trengove
M, Egan

B, Muston
M, Robinson

D, Currie
A, Cordy

M, Brown
S, Gumbleton

[mog_dog00]

Matei'm no expert but i'd give it 8 or so out of10.
Mcphee could pan out to be a decent catch at his price, little risky wit cousins, hasleby and higgins. i'd prob get rid of hasleby there. But solid looking forward line - little bit injury prone i'd swap n. brown with deledio - he's way fitter, stronger and durable. yea having porpylzia, chapman, n. brown - bit of a risk considering each of their recent history. But that article the other day mentioned chappas wanting more time in the middle and he's modified program this preseason has got his body in good nick. alas, i still will not pick him from the get go. with j.brown potentially being a slow starter there as well.   lol and houlian?? he seems a little popular from what i've seen - wat r u thinking there make money off him or u think he'll step up?? i don't know wat his price is and personally don't care! What is Houlians role at Carlton anyway?? surely they've got enough rebounding defenders..is he just a utility whose role changes weekly?? but kickass backline there!

[DT ELITE]

Cheers mate, it will be risky with so many injured players  but i will probs make adjustments depending on form in the NAB cup. Also most players returning from injury such as houlihan are at discounted prices. So if they perform as well as previous yrs they will go up. Its a risk but, no guts no glory.

[chris]

First thing I prob notice is you only have 2 Geelong players one of which is Egan who most likely will miss a fair chunk of this season. Now that's OK except probably in your midfield no Ablett, Bartel, Corey, Selwood or Ling. I would have one of Ablett, Bartel or Corey as my No.1 premium mid or Judd or Hodge.