Hille to Seaby?

[Carnthedockers]

1st trade for the season, should I swap hille for Seaby? I think he could be the Mitch clark of last year...

[daddsy404]

exactly what im thinking

[Flame]

Hille got 65 after a slow start..Well he had a good finish. How will you feel if he comes good?? In saying that i have Seaby and am very happy!! Hoping he has a Mitch Clark year.

[daddsy404]

i think he will have a great year, but id just be gutted if i got seaby and hille started dominating, i really like him as a player as well which makes it even more difficult

[Carnthedockers]

Which way you leaning Daddsy? I am determined not to blow trades this year. But this could be a winner...

[daddsy404]

im really leaning towards seaby, its now or never as well seeing as he has a b/e of -43 as well
am also debating about hall to brown ??????

[daddsy404]

its really hard to ignore the 2 scores hes gotten as well, admittedly against not high quality opponents, but he is agile, and the number one ruckman for sydney
its a tough one

[Carnthedockers]

Yep agreed. Hall was always gonna be a dud. Even when he kicked 7 in pre season he still only just cracked the hundred.. Get brown.

[daddsy404]

yeh am starting to think its definitely the right option, hate to waste trade/s this early in the season, having said that it is from the look of the first two games a definite beneficial trade

[Cruiseon]

Seaby will come back to the pack, dont trade him in, alhough this week he has Richmond!!

[footy phantom]

just wanted to get anyone's opinion on trading hille for seaby?

have sandi as first ruck with warnock and trengrove as subs.

i am happy with hille's start, im just not sure whether i should consider seaby before his price changes.

im yet to make a trade and scored 2,246 (457 weekly ranking) so sitting alright and not sure if its a waste of a trade - understand theyre gold come finals time.

thanks

[elephants]

now you mention it im tempted.

what about hall out danger in and hille out seaby in .

afetr that i probly wont trade for ages...

[Tigerssss]

Hille for Seaby? or not?

[MissPiesFF]

Hille for seaby hmm, why not trade one of your benchies for seaby if you have some cash in the kitty. Then decide on Hille further down the track..and maybe bench him for a bit. Yes it cost money but could save you later on. Seaby is cheaper than Nicnat too(I think??) Then if Hille picks up and Seaby has become a fine cash cow...you will come up trumps on rucks and money in a few rounds.

[Carnthedockers]

Is hille to seaby a waste of a trade? Or is seaby likely to dominate with the number one role?