Riewoldt vs J.Brown

[reesbr]

Who is the better player????? 

Please share your thoughts  :)

[ossie85]

Very tough choice. But I'd choose Brown first if I was selecting a real football team.

Riewoldt an incredibly close second though.

Brown on goal kicking? Just.

[Justin Bieber]

its too close to call for me. both are great leaders and can tear teams apart. brown i think has more courage in him so would choose him ahead of roo in a real team like ossie.

[Master Q]

DT, Roo. Real footy, Brown NO DOUBT! Brown is such a head ache for teams and i can't recall roo being double teamed.

[Hawka]

wat about buddy sure he is inaccurte but he is younger and has much more potential then voldt and brown
he kicked 100 goals in  year something brown or riewoldt havent
i would have to pick browny but buddy should be up there as well
yes im a hawks supporter but i reckon he can be better then them 2

[ELLsendon]

Very tough choice. But I'd choose Brown first if I was selecting a real football team.

Riewoldt an incredibly close second though.

Brown on goal kicking? Just.

Agreed. Brown on goalkicking

[yeahsup]

Brown.
Simple.
Better goal kicking.
And as they were talking about this morning on one of the footy shows, he's a big solid tough guy. He runs into the mid.
Riewoldt doesn't.
Brown has Riewoldt covered and more.

[ossie85]

wat about buddy sure he is inaccurte but he is younger and has much more potential then voldt and brown

1 great season so far, ask me in 7 years

[Master Q]

wat about buddy sure he is inaccurte but he is younger and has much more potential then voldt and brown
he kicked 100 goals in  year something brown or riewoldt havent
i would have to pick browny but buddy should be up there as well
yes im a hawks supporter but i reckon he can be better then them 2

Nice Joke ;D

[Blakeyboy88]

Jonathan Brown all the way mate.
he is more experienced, has played and won grand finals.
He is bigger, faster, stronger.
He, in my expert opinion, is the most accurate kick in the competition.
He does not cry when he gets injured, unlike Riewoldt.
Is actually agressive in the way he plays.
He has a better run-up for set shots.
He is not a selfish player, and very much loves to set the ball up to team-mates.
Nick Riewoldt is an unexperienced, weak, slow, inaccurate, soft, umpire-friendly, selfish cry-baby.
I hope you agree.
Go Pies :)

[ossie85]

he is more experienced, has played and won grand finals.

What, you think if it was Riewoldt in the Lions team and not Brown the Lions wouldn't have won those three flags?

Riewoldt isn't selfish, and unexperienced?! That's just rubbish

[Blakeyboy88]

he is more experienced, has played and won grand finals.

What, you think if it was Riewoldt in the Lions team and not Brown the Lions wouldn't have won those three flags?

No, genius, I said that he has more experience because he has played and won grand finals.  ::)

[Master Q]

Nick Riewoldt is an unexperienced, weak, slow, inaccurate, soft, umpire-

What cr@p you going to say next? I also think JB is better but Roo isn't bad.

[Blakeyboy88]

Nick Riewoldt is an unexperienced, weak, slow, inaccurate, soft, umpire-

What cr@p you going to say next? I also think JB is better but Roo isn't bad.

Roo IS unexperienced, he has played in 2 or 3 finals series in his whole career.
He also cannot play in the midfield, like Jonathan Brown does when he pushes up.

[Justin Bieber]

Nick Riewoldt is an unexperienced, weak, slow, inaccurate, soft, umpire-

What cr@p you going to say next? I also think JB is better but Roo isn't bad.

Roo IS unexperienced, he has played in 2 or 3 finals series in his whole career.
He also cannot play in the midfield, like Jonathan Brown does when he pushes up.

you do know they both play similar roles. brown and roo both push up the field alot. brown doesn't play in the midfield. they were experimenting last year. the saints don't need another midfield = Roo stays at CHF.