2024 SC

[Ashmore62]

Def: Sicily, Sinclair, Young, Williams, Curtin, Gibcus. Bench: Pink, Coffield

Mids: Bont, Petracca, N Daicos, Walsh, Miller, Mckercher, Sanders, J Clark. Bench: Sharp, Sinn, Bedendo.

Ruck: Gawn, Grundy. Bench: Maley.

Forwards: Macrae, Flanders, Lynch, Harmes, Reid, D Wilson. Bench: Kreuger, Mannagh.

Happy new year . 57k itb. thoughts.

[Ashmore62]

Take 2

Def: N Daicos,Sicily,Coleman, Williams, Curtin, Gibcus. Bench: Pink, Coffield

Mids: Bont, Petracca, Butters, Walsh, Miller, Mckercher, Sanders, D Wilson. Bench: Sharp, Sinn, Clark.

Ruck: Marshall, Grundy. Bench: Maley.

Forwards: J Macrae, Flanders, Lynch, Fyfe, Reid, F Macrae. Bench: S Darcy, Mannagh.

35k itb.

[Bully]

Take 2

Def: N Daicos,Sicily,Coleman, Williams, Curtin, Gibcus. Bench: Pink, Coffield

Mids: Bont, Petracca, Butters, Walsh, Miller, Mckercher, Sanders, D Wilson. Bench: Sharp, Sinn, Clark.

Ruck: Marshall, Grundy. Bench: Maley.

Forwards: J Macrae, Flanders, Lynch, Fyfe, Reid, F Macrae. Bench: S Darcy, Mannagh.

35k itb.

Decent structure, I'm going for something similar although I'm slightly concerned about Gibcus onfield, I think he's ok for the bench but there's every chance he plays forward this year and that could impact his scoring potential. Balta will get first dibs but I personally prefer Gibcus as Riewoldt's replacement, Balta still refining his forward credentials.

Rookies are solid, Mannagh a great pick if the Cats give him an early shot, Pink seems like a leftfield selection but you never know. Fin Macrae could be an inspired pick, 3rd year usually indicates a 60+ average.

Flanders seems quite risky, very awkward pricing, has to be a keeper and that's not an absolute guarantee although the forwards look light this year.

Rucks have some good options, I'd be choosing from English, Marshall, Gawn, Grundy and perhaps Darcy if his body is ok.

Bont at over 700k seems pricey, I'm wondering if it would be better to wait and maybe pick a cheaper mid like Laird. Oliver a steer clear this year, looks like he's joined the burnman collective.

[Ringo]

Only comment is watch the number of Round 0 players you have given these have the early byes where other teams may get the jump on you. Would try to limit to 2/3 prems from Rd 0.

[Ashmore62]

Is Naismith to risky at R2 if Yank doesn't come up??

[ubeaut]

Is Naismith to risky at R2 if Yank doesn't come up??

yes too risky. Will lose his spot once Nank returns

Could you please look and comment on my team!

[Mat0369]

Is Naismith to risky at R2 if Yank doesn't come up??

Way too risky. I think he is a good R3 in that case, but if Nank is ready by round 2 you have no price rise and have to burn a trade on a premium to recover the ruck situation.