WXV Trade Confabulation 2022

[Purple 77]

3 coaches still to vote.

The following trades auto-pass (unless they are dependent on another trade)

Trade 20
Dublin trade: Jayden Hunt + Christchurch Future 2nd Round Pick
Berlin trade: Brodie Smith

Trade 23
Cairo trade: Taylor Adams + Cairo Future 4th Round Pick
Buenos Aires trade: Jimmy Webster + Pick 18

[Purple 77]

All coaches have voted

Trade 19
London trade: Jack Lukosius, Jacob Van Rooyen + Pick 63
Berlin trade: Darcy Wilmot, Bailey Fritsch + Pick 53
3 votes - autopass

Trade 21
Cairo trade: Riley Collier-Dawkins + Pick 82
Cape Town trade: Nick Murray
1 vote - autopass



Trade 22
Rio de Janeiro trade: Daniel Rich, Will Day, Pick 15 + Pick 52
Rio de Janeiro receive: Lachie Weller, Nathan Broad, Sam Collins + Denver Grainger-Barras

Toronto trade: Nathan Broad, Denver Grainger-Barras + Toronto Future 2nd Round Pick
Toronto receive: Daniel Rich + Pick 52

Seoul trade: Lachie Weller + Sam Collins
Seoul receive: Will Day, Pick 15 + Toronto Future 2nd Round Pick

This trade received 7 votes, meaning it has failed, but I have the ability to overturn into a pass.

Coaches were consistent in the reasons, feeling Seoul was receiving too much for what they were giving, and also felt Rio was giving too much for what they were receiving. Many coaches suggested removing Pick 15 from the deal would solve in the imbalance. No coaches mentioned Toronto's involvement at any point.

I won't labour the point - I see the merit in what the coaches are saying, noting Weller and Collins posted 81 and 68 averages respectively in what could be argued in the prime of their career, compared to Will Day posting 66, with an argument (not saying he will) for improvement. The inherit argument is that their value (one a 1 for 1 basis) isn't dissimilar, and the gap isn't as wide as Pick 15 + Future 2nd suggests.  I'm not saying I agree one way or the other, but I'd conclude the coaches weren't unreasonable in their assessments of value.

Thus, the trade remains REJECTED

I'll be posting the reasons to the coaches involved.

[Purple 77]

I mentioned in Discord, but this trade

Trade 24
New York trade: Jack Williams + New York Future 1st Round Pick
Mexico City trade: Lachie Hunter + Jacob Weitering

auto-passed



Spreadsheet updated for those interested

2022 WXV Trade Centre

[Purple 77]

All except 1 coach has voted (boo Urbs. To clarify, not saying boo-urns)

These trades auto-pass

Trade 25
Buenos Aires trade: Jarrod Berry + Jack Ginnivan
Tokyo trade: Zac Williams + Tokyo Future 2nd Round Pick

Trade 27
Rio de Janeiro trade: Daniel Rich, Will Day + Pick 52
Rio de Janeiro receive: Lachie Weller, Nathan Broad, Denver Grainger-Barras + Seoul Future 4th Round Pick

Toronto trade: Nathan Broad, Denver Grainger-Barras + Toronto Future 2nd Round Pick
Toronto receive: Daniel Rich + Pick 52

Seoul trade: Lachie Weller + Seoul Future 4th Round Pick
Seoul receive: Will Day + Toronto Future 2nd Round Pick

Trade 28
New York trade: Caleb Daniel + Jacob Weitering + Jake Kelly
Dublin trade: Christian Salem + Brodie Smith + Brandan Parfitt



This trade received 6 votes, meaning it has failed but I have the ability to overturn it to a pass.

Trade 26
Seoul trade: Seoul Future 1st Round Pick + Buenos Aires Future 1st Round Pick
Tokyo trade: Tokyo Future 1st Round Pick

All coaches expressed concerns on the strong likelihood of Tokyo overpaying in this trade, given Seoul and Buenos Aires have genuine top 4 claims next year, whilst Tokyo may be more likely to finish in the bottom half of the ladder.

I think this trade was the reason why we (the community) had initial reservations in allowing the trading of future 1st round selections. Irrespective of the possibility of Tokyo profitting this trade, the potential for it go pear-shaped for a team whom finished bottom of the ladder, and whom didn't hedge their bets by including a known quantity in the trade... I think I may have even rejected it if it landed on 4-5 votes.

Trade is rejected.

Reasons will be PMed to Seoul and Tokyo.

[iZander]

I am looking to add one additional forward to my squad, preferably 70-75+ averaging forward if young-mid age or slightly higher on the older side

[fanTCfool]

Toronto Wolves

Defenders
Inclined to Offload: Alex Witherden, Michael Hibberd, James Borlase, Tom Williamson, Sam Skinner
Indifferent: Daniel Rich, Trey Ruscoe, Miller Bergman, Jake Stein
Inclined to Keep: Tom Atkins (MID), Ryan Burton, Liam Baker, Jack Buckley
Strongly Inclined to Keep: Jake Bowey

Midfielders
Indifferent: Tim Kelly, Dion Prestia, Will Setterfield, Dan Hannebery
Inclined to Keep: Jai Newcombe, Lachlan Sholl, Josh Goater, Jackson Mead, Marcus Windhager
Strongly Inclined to Keep: Jackson Macrae

Rucks
Inclined to Keep: Jacob Edwards (FWD)
Strongly Inclined to Keep: Rowan Marshall (FWD)

Forwards
Inclined to Offload: Ben Brown, Marc Sheather, Lachlan Rankin
Indifferent: Zac Fisher, Jack Silvagni, Joe Daniher, Sam Weideman, Josh Corbett, Josh Morris (DEF)
Inclined to Keep: Connor MacDonald (MID), Max King
Strongly Inclined to Keep: Isaac Heeney, Josh Rachele



NAT Selections: 10, 51, 64, 85
PSD Selections: 10, 28, 46
Future Selections: 1st, 3rd, Cairo's 3rd, Christchurch's 4th, 5th



Updated following trades.
Open to moving a starting quality forward for an equivalent defender or midfielder.
Looking to split Pick 10, either into two later picks or player/s.
Future first rounder on the table for those interested in sweating on my downfall.

[Purple 77]

Seeking defenders and cap. Multiple forwards and draft picks available.

[Purple 77]

All except 2 coaches have voted (boo Mexico City, Christchurch)

All trades auto-pass



Trade 29
Seoul trade: Josh Rotham
London trade: Jake Waterman

Trade 30
Rio de Janeiro trade: Pick 51
Pacific trade: Jake Kolodjashnij

Trade 31
Buenos Aires trade: Corey Durdin + Buenos Aires Future 2nd Round Pick
Christchurch trade: Paddy Dow

Trade 32
Toronto trade: Elliot Yeo, Pick 43 + Pick 49
Seoul trade: Zac Fisher, Will Setterfield + Pick 84

[Purple 77]

All except 3 teams have voted.

Trade 33
New York trade: Luke Dunstan + Pick 62
Rio de Janeiro trade: Pick 36 + Pick 69

Trade 34
Berlin trade:  Pick 60 + Pick 78
Pacific trade: Tim O'Brien + Pick 92

Trade 35
Dublin trade: Dublin Future 3rd Round Pick
Cairo trade: Dan Butler


All trades auto-pass

[Purple 77]

Trade period closure date (players): Sunday 27 November at 6.00pm AEDST

[Purple 77]

Trade 36
Berlin trade: Pick 21, Pick 42 + Pick 92
Seoul trade: Ed Curnow, Nathan Wilson, Sam Day + Pick 24

Trade 37
Berlin trade: Pick 32
PNL trade: Jayden Laverde

Trade 38
London trade: Nick Hind
Buenos Aires: Riley Bonner + Taylor Adams

Autopassed

[iZander]

Dillos

Defenders
Inclined to Offload: Bonar, Brock, O'Riordan
Indifferent: Hind, Williams, Hurn, Doedee, Coffield, Highmore, Walker, Francis
Inclined to Keep: Ash, Campbell
Strongly Inclined to Keep: Scrimshaw, Short

Midfielders
Inclined to Offload: LOB
Indifferent: Wines, Dow
Inclined to Keep: Parish, Roberts, Sharp
Strongly Inclined to Keep: Green, Serong, Cerra, Macrae, Owens

Rucks
Indifferent:
Inclined to Keep:
Strongly Inclined to Keep: ROB, Strachan, Lane

Forwards
Inclined to Offload: Brockman, Ronke
Indifferent: Johnson, Nankervis
Inclined to Keep: JDG, Dusty, Hayward
Strongly Inclined to Keep: Greene, Rayner, Jeffrey, Mcdonald

Happy to look at any last minute deals
Ideally id add another fwd
Could probably trade one of my defenders, either straight or in a package

[Purple 77]

Cairo, Rio and Mexico City yet to vote.

Both trades decided.

Trade 40
Dublin trade: James Harmes + Pick 41
Rome trade: Jack Ziebell, Pick 12 + Pick 54

auto-passes


Trade 39
Christchurch trade: Rory Lobb
London trade: London Future 1st Round Pick

Has received 7 votes. All think London are overpaying, pointing towards the likelihood of a top 5-10 draft pick for a player that isn't certain to get RUC status.

I don't disagree with the coaches enough to overturn the decision.

Trade is rejected.

Reasons will be sent to coaches shortly

[Purple 77]

1 week left

[Purple 77]

Seeking defenders. Picks 16, 24 and 30 available. Jamie Cripps also available for those seeking a 70+ forward, but would need commensurate cap in return