WXV Trade Confabulation 2021

[Nige]

Bit of interest in Bailey Dale, somewhat open to the idea of moving him. Pretty confident he remains a 90+ def which don't grow on trees so ideally want an offer in the following mold:
- a reasonably good starting mid
- a combo of decent mids
- a mid + decent pick

Happy to discuss things in Discord DMs as always

[fanTCfool]

TT Lynch has been my most inquired about player, perhaps unsurprisingly considering the state of 2022 forwards. Since returning from his well publicised toe injury, he's averaged 85.4 89, so I'd say an 80+ average is pretty attainable next season. My first preference would be to combine Lynch with one of my non-Macrae midfielders for a midfielder in return. Alternatively, I'd consider straight swapping for a midfielder or defender, with a straight swap for a draft pick my least preferred trade avenue.

Slide into my DMs  :-*

[Ringo]

Different format for me:

Green readily tradeable
Orange - Available for reasonable offer
Red - Staying unless insane offers made.



Looking for higher scoring players so can mix and match with picks as well.

Have updated.  Apologies as I probably needed to work out some forwards to retain and decided on Jake Waterman and Higgis,  Overlooked that when initially posting.

[Purple 77]

Everyone has a price on my list.

I wouldn't ask for Cripps tho. I don't know what the sunk cost fallacy is.

But I may offer him.

[DazBurg]

Defenders
Could be Moved: Marcus Adams,  Matt Buntine, Jackson Nelson,  Jack Madgen,
Probably Staying: Luke Ryan, Hunter Clark, Darcy Moore, Michael Hurley, Dougal Howard, Charlie Ballard, Sam De Koning

Midfielders
Could be Moved: Bailey Smith, Ryan Angwin, Carter Michael, Tom Hird, Matthew Kennedy, Trent Cotchin, Nathan Jones,
Probably Staying:  Zach Merrett, Jack Billings, Ben Keays, Paul Seedsman, Will Brodie,  Jay Rantall,

Rucks
Probably Staying:Tom Hickey, Marc Pittonet, Sam Naismith, Joel Amartey, Ned Reeves, Max Lynch


Forwards
Could be Moved: Jayden Laverde, Jack Lonie, Josh Schache, Lachlan Murphy, Jarrod Cameron, Nikolas Cox
Probably Staying: Steele Sidebottom, Robbie Gray, Mitch Wallis, Oscar Allen, Darcy Cameron,  Ben King

Done a rough one wouldn't say no to nearly anyone except probably merrett or ryan would take mammoth offers
some i put as no can end up changing had no thought of trading smith and few others till people actually expressed interest so you never know

[Pkbaldy]

Com Tole available.

[GoLions]

hmu

Should probs do a proper post ay

Don't have anyone off the table, tbh the only players I'd say with confidence won't be traded are Mills and Harris, but you never know. Also i am aware that some of these player positions may/will change.

Probably target from here will be a starting forward, and possibly getting back into the draft. Have a lot of F4/F5 (or worse heh) type forwards that can be packaged for anyone needing depth.



Defenders
On the Market: Brock Smith
Could be Moved: Luke McDonald, Brad Sheppard, Jaxon Prior, Griffin Logue, Will Hamill
Probably Staying: Harris Andrews, Jack Bowes, Isaac Quaynor, Trent Rivers

Midfielders
On the Market: Lewis Taylor, Thomas Hutchesson
Could be Moved: Ben Cunnington, Deven Robertson, Ely Smith, James Cousins, Quinton Narkle
Probably Staying: Callum Mills, Jaeger O'Meara, Mitch Duncan, Tanner Bruhn

Rucks
Probably Staying: Toby Nankervis, Ivan Soldo, Mabior Chol, Callum Coleman-Jones, Samson Ryan

Forwards
On the Market: Shane McAdam, Mitch Crowden, Dean Kent, Taylor Garner, Kade Chandler, Connor Ballenden, Trent Burgoyne
Could be Moved: Ben Ainsworth, Gryan Miers, Josh Battle, Shaun Higgins
Probably Staying: Tom Papley, Jaidyn Stephenson, Chadley Warner

[Nige]

Gotta do the right thing and let the people know publicly of course.

There's a distinct possibility Bailey Dale could be on the move by this time tomorrow

[Purple 77]

8 votes in

Trade 1
Dublin trade: Dustin Martin, Toby Greene, Jeremy Howe, Jack Gunston + Shannon Hurn
Buenos Aires trade: Andrew Brayshaw, Patrick Lipinski, Brodie Kemp, Jordan Roughead, Jayden Hunt + Pick 29

Has received 6 votes. I've shared the reasons with iZ and Holz. All of them suggest BA need to give more. I won't overturn the decision to a PASS either.

Trade is rejected.

[Boomz]

Tokyo

Looking for premium mids/fwds. Thilthorpe has had a lot of interest and is likely to be traded.

All picks available:
NAT PICKS: 6, 25, 43, 61, 79
PSD PICKS: 6, 24, 42
FUTURE PICKS: 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th

Available: Seb Ross, Michael Gibbons, Nick Holman, James Rowe, Matt Guelfi, Rory Atkins, Harry Cunningham, Lachie Plowman, Brayden Cook, Dylan Williams, Xavier O'Halloran, Matthew Cottrell, Martin Frederick, Ian Hill, Ben Long

Could be moved: Riley Thilthorpe, Daniel Rioli, Michael Walters, Cody Weightman, Charlie Cameron, Liam Ryan, Oliver Florent, Zac Williams, Isaac Smith

Unlikely (feel free to try): Jacob Hopper, Jordan Ridley, Lachie Whitfield, Josh Dunkley, Peter Ladhams, Scott Lycett, Tom Liberatore, Jarman Impey

[Purple 77]

2 teams left to vote.

Noting that 8+ negs is auto-fail, and 3 votes or less is auto-pass, the following have been decided.

(black text is means it is pending)

Trade 1
Dublin trade: Dustin Martin, Toby Greene, Jeremy Howe, Jack Gunston + Shannon Hurn
Buenos Aires trade: Andrew Brayshaw, Patrick Lipinski, Brodie Kemp, Jordan Roughead, Jayden Hunt + Pick 29

Trade 2
Dublin trade: Dylan Shiel, Dyson Heppell, Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti, Minairo Frederick + Pick 11
Beijing trade: Caleb Daniel, Pick 7, Pick 26 + Pick 44

Trade 3
Dublin trade: Rory Sloane + Josh P Kennedy
Berlin trade: James Harmes + Pick 32

Trade 4
Seoul trade: Seoul Future 3rd Round Pick
Mexico City trade: Mexico City Future 3rd Round Pick

Trade 5
Cape Town trade: Liam Shiels
London trade: Brad Sheppard

Trade 6
Christchurch trade: Isaac Quaynor + Deven Robertson
Cape Town trade: Sam Menegola + Pick 12

Trade 7
Beijing trade: Dan Houston, Chayce Jones + Pick 11
Moscow trade: Stephen Coniglio, Tom Hawkins + Moscow Future 2nd Round Pick

Trade 8
New York trade: Brandon Starcevich + Pick 28
Moscow trade: Pick 19

Trade 9
New York trade: Andrew McGrath, Izak Rankine + Pick 19
Dublin trade: Caleb Daniel + Pick 30

Trade 10
New York trade: Jade Gresham, Fischer McAsey, Conor Stone + Pick 9
Cairo trade: Bailey Dale, Pick 22 + Pick 40

Trade 11
Toronto trade: James Bell + Pick 52
Mexico City trade: Trey Ruscoe + Pick 73

Trade 12
Toronto trade: Luke Shuey, Tom T Lynch + Damon Greaves
PNL trade: Matthew Kennedy, Pick 14 + Pick 87

Trade 13
Berlin trade: Patrick Cripps, Logan McDonald + Berlin Future 2nd Round Pick
Seoul trade: Luke Jackson, Darcy Fogarty + Mexico City Future 3rd Round Pick

Trade 14
PNL trade: Bailey Smith
Dublin trade: Matt Crouch

Trade 15
New York trade: Pick 46
New Delhi trade: Josh J Kennedy

Trade 16
Moscow trade: Scott Pendlebury
PNL trade: Nikolas Cox

Trade 17
Beijing trade: Moscow Future 2nd Round Pick + Beijing Future 3rd Round Pick
Toronto trade: Connor Blakely + Marlion Pickett

Trade 18
Dublin trade: Brad Crouch
New York trade: Will Phillips

[Purple 77]

Trade 14
PNL trade: Bailey Smith
Dublin trade: Matt Crouch

Auto passes

Trade 18
Dublin trade: Brad Crouch
New York trade: Will Phillips

4 negs saying Crouch > Phillips
2 negs saying Phillips > Crouch

I think the mixed results just reflects Phillips mixed 1st year! The reasons provided by the coaches provide valid arguments for both sides, so that sounds like a valid trade to me.

I'm overturning this result from a FAIL to a PASS

[Purple 77]

3 teams left to vote:
- Beijing
- London
- Rio de Janeiro

Trade 20
Cairo trade: Pick 9, Pick 58 + Cairo Future 2nd Round Pick
Mexico City trade: Jordan Clark, Riley Collier-Dawkins + Noah Balta

Trade 21
Cairo trade: Oleg Markov + Tom Sparrow
Berlin trade: Tom J Lynch, Sam Frost + Daniel Lloyd

above trades have received zero negs, so will auto-pass

[Purple 77]

Trade 19
Dublin trade: Dustin Martin, Toby Greene, Jeremy Howe, Jack Gunston + Shannon Hurn
Buenos Aires trade: Andrew Brayshaw, Patrick Lipinski, Brodie Kemp, Jordan Roughead, Jayden Hunt + Pick 10

Received 8 votes, and thus is auto-rejected.

All reasons suggested that Buenos Aires haven't adequately addressed the imbalance identified in the first attempt of this trade.

Trade is rejected.

[RaisyDaisy]

There's a fair chance that Tom Doedee could be traded soon

I've had quite a few coaches ask about him so to those coaches, or anyone else who is interested in him, consider this your notice to get an offer to me now before he goes