2021 Player X vs. Player Y

[Bully]

I need to field two of the following

Jones
Highmore
Madden
Murphy

Which two?

Jones & Highmore

[whynot102]

Murphy and Highmore

I need to field two of the following

Jones
Highmore
Madden
Murphy

Which two?

Jones & Highmore

[Mat0369]

Actually ended up making a change and keeping Kosi. So it's two of Jones, Highmore, Kosi and Murphy. Would you field Kosi over Highmore/Jones.

[Bully]

Actually ended up making a change and keeping Kosi. So it's two of Jones, Highmore, Kosi and Murphy. Would you field Kosi over Highmore/Jones.

Probably not, Jones tired a little bit last week but was on track for a 60. I'd put that down to a lack of match fitness, the very reason I wouldn't play Murphy.

[Ringo]

Actually ended up making a change and keeping Kosi. So it's two of Jones, Highmore, Kosi and Murphy. Would you field Kosi over Highmore/Jones.

Probably not, Jones tired a little bit last week but was on track for a 60. I'd put that down to a lack of match fitness, the very reason I wouldn't play Murphy.

Any chance of looping at all.  I am looping Jones and Murphy.

[Mat0369]

Nope. I have 4 prems and those 4 rookies down back

[B.]

Obviously Whitfield is a great pick and he could fill my D6 but that would mean leaving Laird at M7 and only getting one more premium mid.
Or swing Laird back to D6 and get 2 more premium mids at M7 and 8.

Would you pass on Whitfield to bring in 2 more premium Mids?

Think Guthrie/Bont and Lyons are too far out of reach now so what value picks are the best in the mids out of Duncan/Fyfe/Boak/Kelly/Petracca?

[Bully]

Obviously Whitfield is a great pick and he could fill my D6 but that would mean leaving Laird at M7 and only getting one more premium mid.
Or swing Laird back to D6 and get 2 more premium mids at M7 and 8.

Would you pass on Whitfield to bring in 2 more premium Mids?

Think Guthrie/Bont and Lyons are too far out of reach now so what value picks are the best in the mids out of Duncan/Fyfe/Boak/Kelly/Petracca?

Whitfield capable of matching those mids and has a nice draw, at a tick over 500k I reckon there's solid value. Neale another wait and see.

[Woppa15]

Final Defender (unless I get lucky and trade up May)
Who should it be?
Mills? Lloyd? Whitfield?
Mills playing pure mid.
Lloyd is, well, Lloyd.
Whitfield real value at 500k, potential to match it with the premo mids

I suppose I should mention Hurn at 400k also  :o

Laird. Docherty. Stewart. Ridley. May. Rookies…
Oliver. Macrae. Guthrie. Steele. Walsh. Jordan. Poulter. RCD. Bench Rookies…
Grundy. Gawn. CCJ
Zorko. Ziebell. Martin. Impey. Daniher. Heeney. Bench Rookies x2
$410k bank 13 trades

[Bully]

Hurn's bye might be moved which is good in a way but now that includes Dusty, Short & CCJ. Might be better to grab Whitfield for that round 14 cover.

[jfitty]

Hurn a great buy for mine, grabbed him myself

[whynot102]

CCJ or Bianco

[Bully]

CCJ or Bianco

CCJ

[Thewizz71]

Boak or Kelly?
Whitfield or Hall?
Looking at RCD, Rowe and Jordan out for Reeves and 2 of the above?
Currently leaning towards Kelly and Whitfield.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Boak or Kelly?
Whitfield or Hall?
Looking at RCD, Rowe and Jordan out for Reeves and 2 of the above?
Currently leaning towards Kelly and Whitfield.

Whitfield and Kelly for mine

How about Hall v Hawkins?