Who to bring in for Howe?

Started by RoughRed, June 27, 2020, 12:14:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Ringo

merged both threads and kept poll.

frenzy


Thewizz71

ATM have gone Howe/Stewart -> Ridley/TMitch.
Likely to change numerous times before Thursday.
Also thinking of including Simpkin at some stage.

Dmoney$

Such a hard decision
It’s either Brayden Maynard or Caleb Daniel for me. Caleb would definitely be the safer option due to the unknown of Maynards potential role change to help fill the void of Howe, but if that means more kick outs hence more points then it could be the ultimate power move, what are people’s opinions?

shaker

Quote from: Dmoney$ on July 02, 2020, 02:39:30 AM
Such a hard decision
It’s either Brayden Maynard or Caleb Daniel for me. Caleb would definitely be the safer option due to the unknown of Maynards potential role change to help fill the void of Howe, but if that means more kick outs hence more points then it could be the ultimate power move, what are people’s opinions?
Well you answered your own question you know what Daniel's role will be.

tkringle

Will McKenna’s return impact Ridleys current role?

jfitty

Quote from: tkringle on July 02, 2020, 09:49:57 AM
Will McKenna’s return impact Ridleys current role?

Does McKenna even fit back in the team?

With Ridley, Redman, Gleeson, Saad, Francis plus Hurley and Hooker all in defence.. Don't know?

Either way, I don't think he would affect Ridley too much.

tkringle

Quote from: jfitty on July 02, 2020, 10:27:45 AM
Quote from: tkringle on July 02, 2020, 09:49:57 AM
Will McKenna’s return impact Ridleys current role?

Does McKenna even fit back in the team?

With Ridley, Redman, Gleeson, Saad, Francis plus Hurley and Hooker all in defence.. Don't know?

Either way, I don't think he would affect Ridley too much.

think he was named before the COVID test, so looks like they want to play him

MontyJnr

Weird there isn't much love for Sicily. I'd trust him over Ridley, Maynard & Haynes.

Dmoney$

Sicily can be inconsistent I’ve had him the last few years, he has like 5 games of 80 or under in a row at times then has 2-3 games in a row where he’ll score 120+
In saying that his position has changed a bit this year and with the inclusion of Frost he is able to play permanent spare man

Gavdroid

Is anyone considering Casboult? Has 3 tons and one poor game, and is fwd/def. Can he keep up the decent scoring?

tommy10

Quote from: MontyJnr on July 02, 2020, 11:41:52 AM
Weird there isn't much love for Sicily. I'd trust him over Ridley, Maynard & Haynes.
Unless he has a brain snap and gets suspended  :P

Goosey

Quote from: Gavdroid on July 02, 2020, 06:12:06 PM
Is anyone considering Casboult? Has 3 tons and one poor game, and is fwd/def. Can he keep up the decent scoring?
Gave it some thought but could only bring myself to do it in AF!

HappyDEZ

Quote from: HappyDEZ on June 29, 2020, 12:46:40 PM
No love for Crisp here by the looks. Solid option imo. Def a better option than Maynard for mine.
Very bad call by me. Watched the footy last night & Maynard was unbelievable in the 1st half. Pure intensity & determination. Straight at it like a man possessed. Seen he was 74SC at the half. Probs deserved another 15-20 on top of that. Winning one on ones, one on twos & even a one on three. Maybe one clanger to go with the dozen or so pieces of exceptional football. He absolutely thrived in the wet. Crisp on the other hand....

frenzy

Quote from: HappyDEZ on July 04, 2020, 01:16:26 PM
Quote from: HappyDEZ on June 29, 2020, 12:46:40 PM
No love for Crisp here by the looks. Solid option imo. Def a better option than Maynard for mine.
Very bad call by me. Watched the footy last night & Maynard was unbelievable in the 1st half. Pure intensity & determination. Straight at it like a man possessed. Seen he was 74SC at the half. Probs deserved another 15-20 on top of that. Winning one on ones, one on twos & even a one on three. Maybe one clanger to go with the dozen or so pieces of exceptional football. He absolutely thrived in the wet. Crisp on the other hand....

Got burnt by Crisp last season and won't go there again. 'Haha, burnt to a Crisp'