Round 4 Trades

[EA100]

Do I swing Brander forward and trade Sturt for Williamson or go Grundy down to Pittonet and then Sturt up to a premo

[Ringo]

Does anyone have the BE for Hamill and Williamson?

I realised if I make two trades every week I will run out around the end of the season anyway so I may as well use both. My options are the following

Williams (Eagles) to Williamson or Hamill

Kelly/Danger to any player Fyfe and under. So one of Fyfe, Gaff, Duncan, Merrett, Oliver, Walters or Tom Stewart (basically a keeper on any line not named Neale).

I'm leaning towards trading in Williamson. The player I trade in won't see the field anyway with Young at D7.

Hamill 1 and Williamson 4

[Ringo]

Do I swing Brander forward and trade Sturt for Williamson or go Grundy down to Pittonet and then Sturt up to a premo

Sturt is out for at least 4 weeks so in this shortened season bit long to leave on bench not earning cash so I would do that option.

[Mat0369]

Do I swing Brander forward and trade Sturt for Williamson or go Grundy down to Pittonet and then Sturt up to a premo

I'd hold Grundy. I think Williamson is a fine option to keep the cash gen going

Hamill 1 and Williamson 4

Sweet, thanks. Thinking Williamson it is. I think his position is pretty safe with Newman out, although Stocker could be pushing at some point.

[RaisyDaisy]

I think both Williamson and Hamill should be decent picks, all things considered

I'm going with Hamill now

I don't think I will get burnt by passing on Williamson, and I really did like the look of Hamill last week so I'm going to give him the nod. D8 anyway, so shouldn't be too bad

I can see the appeal in grabbing both, but we seem to have more rookies coming through so I'm happy to just grab 1 of them

[jfitty]

I'll go Hamill I think, something exciting about him.

Was Williamson injured earlier in the season? Feel if he was good enough (and healthy) he would have been in the side round 1. I know Newman is out now, but don't rate him as much. Never been a big SC scorer.

Pocket a little extra cash I reckon..

[Mat0369]

Williamson was fit, but he was always going to struggle to get a game ahead of Doc, Newman, Simmo and Samo who had the HB line on lock down. I would have picked him as a wingman but they decided to go with Newnes instead. He was stiff to be left out.

It has also been the first time he has had a real crack at it since his first season. He looked like a future gun early on but has had non stop issues with his back which killed years 2 and 3. He has pace and is a real good user with the ball in hand. He struggled with smaller grounds because his body wasn't built for contested possession footy. He looked really strong against the Cats and was able to stand up in instances he would have been brought to ground in year 1.

[bkimm32]

Anyone else only just bring Sturt in last week and now thinking of trading? Fml

[RaisyDaisy]

Anyone else only just bring Sturt in last week and now thinking of trading? Fml

There's no thinking, he's gone  ;)

Not as bad as normal, considering the amount of trades we have this year

[Wanderer]

I'm going Hamill. You would think Adelaide will continue to blood the youngsters. I have same feeling with Hamill as I did with Rivers and feel relatively confident with both those choices. Williamson seems to miss games from injury and he is more expensive.

[backpocket]

What’s everyone’s thought on Serong ?

[Ringo]

Watch him this week and if he scores ok then consider. He is being talked up as the next Neale

[North Melbournes Finest]

I think I’m going to do Sturt for Williamson, are we all happy with his JS?

[RaisyDaisy]

Butler is every chance of scoring a 30 this week. Small forwards generally don't score well against Richmond.

I've gone for it. Fingers crossed he can score decent for the next two weeks! If not, easy correction for Whitfield anyway.

Well done mate

Has totally surprised me, nice one :)

[dottman]

Cunington and Pattern late outs.