2020 Player X v Player y

[jfitty]

Z Williams v Blicavs v L McDonald

Williams out of those I feel, save some cash.

Still deciding myself between Williams and Saad, Williams just feels like a bit of a boring pick!

[Blues Blues Blues]

Z Williams v Blicavs v L McDonald

Williams out of those I feel, save some cash.

Still deciding myself between Williams and Saad, Williams just feels like a bit of a boring pick!

I thought the same. Just spent some time looking at L McDonald and his last 5 impressive: 122, 136, 95, 138, 119. Also has a Rd 15 bye which doesn’t count for finals [my focus]. Interests me greatly

[barlowlove]

Is Luke Ryan as final DEF premium worth the extra $100k compared to Haynes?

[Mat0369]

Is Luke Ryan as final DEF premium worth the extra $100k compared to Haynes?

It depends how many other spots you need to upgrade and how many trades you have left. I'm against grabbing top priced players (and went against my advice once this season with Treloar). I feel it can backfire and guys will inevitably put in a stinker.

If you need to upgrade another forward or mid I'd pocket the 100k and grab the cheaper option. If it is your final upgrade for your team and your set on having Ryan just pull the trigger. The other thing to consider is it's a 5 round season right now. Do you think Ryan will outscore Haynes from this point on. If you think it's a wash I'd pocket the cash in case of emergency.

[crowls]

Z Williams v Blicavs v L McDonald

Williams out of those I feel, save some cash.

Still deciding myself between Williams and Saad, Williams just feels like a bit of a boring pick!

I thought the same. Just spent some time looking at L McDonald and his last 5 impressive: 122, 136, 95, 138, 119. Also has a Rd 15 bye which doesn’t count for finals [my focus]. Interests me greatly

tempted to do him as cheaper Lloyd option and then only need to upgrade ruck when Gawn is back. 

[crowls]

zerret + maynard v shiel + mcdonald +30K    110+105 v 105 + 115
more potential upside scoring  with mcdonald but downside risk of sheil and mcdonald is scary

Need some additional cash to upgrade ruck before last two finals.  if option 2 have 242k in bank with 4 trades. 
leaves me with 18 scorers assuming sholl, ruscoe and foot all get games in R15 bye.   
Alternative is go for Lloyd now and hope I can generate cash out of Scholl, Close, Xerri, Ruscoe, Bytel with downgrades to 102k non scorers for Rnd 17/18 leaving no cover.      I like to win leagues but not cash leagues this year and overall is more important to me.

[quinny88]

Fyfe or Titch to finish my midfield??

[whynot102]

Titch got both Fyfe to up and down only scored 86 last week Titch 132 quote author=quinny88 link=topic=113569.msg2012201#msg2012201 date=1598430208]
Fyfe or Titch to finish my midfield??
[/quote]

[whynot102]

Lukosius, Jack Martin or Simpkin

[Fid]

Lukosius, Jack Martin or Simpkin

Is there any love for Toby Greene, with no byes?

[timtim]

Lukosius for me. Seems like in classic “coming home with a wet sail going to break out next year “ form haha

But I’d try and get him as D6 because simpkin at his current price is way better value

[whynot102]

Looking at last spot in the fwd line does that change opinions

Lukosius for me. Seems like in classic “coming home with a wet sail going to break out next year “ form haha

But I’d try and get him as D6 because simpkin at his current price is way better value

[Samsturmfels]

Lukosius, Jack Martin or Simpkin

Is there any love for Toby Greene, with no byes?

I can see Greene getting a huge score against the crows (and GWS have a good fixture) although i am getting Jack Martin as i cant afford greene and he is averaging over 100 excluding his injury affected score.

[jfitty]

Trying to decide between some cheaper defenders..

Lukosius vs Sheppard vs McGovern vs May

Could pay up for Maynard, but want to keep some cash in the bank if I can..

[Samsturmfels]

Trying to decide between some cheaper defenders..

Lukosius vs Sheppard vs McGovern vs May

Could pay up for Maynard, but want to keep some cash in the bank if I can..

Id go Lukosious if your not worried about byes. If not i like May or Mcgovern. 8 of the 9 last games for May have been over 90 which is pretty good