2020 Player X v Player y

[whynot102]

Williams three tons in a row and a play maker

Hey guys,

Haven’t posted on here for a while.

Can’t decide between Saad and Williams for my last upgrade down back.

What is everyone’s thoughts?

[quinny88]

Hey guys,

Haven’t posted on here for a while.

Can’t decide between Saad and Williams for my last upgrade down back.

What is everyone’s thoughts?

Weighing this decision up too. Sad has flown under the radar big time. Been very consistent

[Thewizz71]

Hey guys,

Haven’t posted on here for a while.

Can’t decide between Saad and Williams for my last upgrade down back.

What is everyone’s thoughts?

Weighing this decision up too. Sad has flown under the radar big time. Been very consistent

I think Saad as well. I like the dash of both, but I think that Saad will be on the park more.

Lllllllllllloyd vs L Ryan to replace Sicily. Leaning towards Lloyd just for all his cheap touches.

[jvalles69]

I've had Saad for about 5-6 weeks now, one of those guys you don't have to think about, but doesn't have the high ceiling that Zwill does.

[Money Shot]

Thanks for the feedback guys!

Even if it hasn’t helped my decision ::)

[Wanderer]

Thanks for the feedback guys!

Even if it hasn’t helped my decision ::)

If you have enough trades to take the risk on Williams, then do it. If you don't and you are risk averse, then go Saad.

I am getting Williams FWIW.

[Slick5]

Greenwood vs Oscar to finish my forward line??? 

[Money Shot]

Thanks for the feedback guys!

Even if it hasn’t helped my decision ::)

If you have enough trades to take the risk on Williams, then do it. If you don't and you are risk averse, then go Saad.

I am getting Williams FWIW.

Yeah I’ve got some trades up the sleeve and I do think Williams has a higher ceiling.

[JBs-Hawks]

Thanks for the feedback guys!

Even if it hasn’t helped my decision ::)

If you have enough trades to take the risk on Williams, then do it. If you don't and you are risk averse, then go Saad.

I am getting Williams FWIW.

I started Williams but I wouldn’t be bringing him in

[Blues Blues Blues]

Ryan vs Williams (and cash remaining).

[Samsturmfels]

Ryan vs Williams (and cash remaining).

I prefer Williams. He gives you more cash to spend elsewhere. Ryan is more likely to average more for rest of year but he will be playing away from Perth. Williams is more of an injury risk but i do prefer his fixture.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Williams [$487k] vs Witherden [$474k]

Williams last 3: 112, 105, 111
Witherden last 3: 85, 100, 101

Witherden scored a massive 170 in his first game back after being on outer. I assumed he was injured, but Fagan chose to play others before him.

[Samsturmfels]

Williams [$487k] vs Witherden [$474k]

Williams last 3: 112, 105, 111
Witherden last 3: 85, 100, 101

Witherden scored a massive 170 in his first game back after being on outer. I assumed he was injured, but Fagan chose to play others before him.

With Witherden having the bye still I'd rather pick Williams.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Williams [$487k] vs Witherden [$474k]

Williams last 3: 112, 105, 111
Witherden last 3: 85, 100, 101

Witherden scored a massive 170 in his first game back after being on outer. I assumed he was injured, but Fagan chose to play others before him.

With Witherden having the bye still I'd rather pick Williams.

Good call, must admit I failed to check that. Hence the beauty of this forum! THANKS MATE

[Samsturmfels]

Parish (can also get angus) + Rankine (will trade out soon) + Foot        v      Walsh + Cameron + Reid

Have a lack of cash so can only get these sort of guys. Parish has had good recent form but worried about his fixture, while Walsh has an 108 5 game average. If i were to go with Walsh i have to sacrifice my rookies.

Thoughts?