2020 Player X v Player y

[Ringo]

Steven or Ceglar?

I have Naismith at R2

With Naismith at 2 I would go the added protection of Ceglar ensuring you have a R/f at R3

[Ringo]

Gawn & Mid Bench Rookie (Mahoney/Robertson) vs Naismith & Titch

Hard one here Nismith say 75 average and Titch say 120 total 195 v Gawn say 130 so in front there but will be soundly dependent on how quick you can upgrade as both options have only one keeper.

[Samsturmfels]

Roberton (D3)+ Noble (D4) + 133k (to be used elsewhere) v Houston (D3) + Greaves + $300. Have Zerk-Thatcher and Starcevich currently on the field aswell.

[TurtlesTerriers]

Player                   Club   Pos            Price   Games   Mins   TOG%   Pts   PPM 100   Ave          1   2

Darcy MacPherson   GCS   Fwd/Mid   $443,800   2           213   86.2%   259   121.6   129.5   132   127
or
Andrew Brayshaw   FRE   Fwd/Mid   $382,800   2           164   70.5%   196   119.5   98           94   102
or
Tom J. Lynch           RIC   Fwd           $388,800   1           110   90.5%   111   100.9   111              111

i like lynch given all the G games at home, but we all know about key fwds.
GCS as per another thread here, ??
so leaves me with brayshaw

[whynot102]

Cogs or Yeo

[Pokerface]

Player                   Club   Pos            Price   Games   Mins   TOG%   Pts   PPM 100   Ave          1   2

Darcy MacPherson   GCS   Fwd/Mid   $443,800   2           213   86.2%   259   121.6   129.5   132   127
or
Andrew Brayshaw   FRE   Fwd/Mid   $382,800   2           164   70.5%   196   119.5   98           94   102
or
Tom J. Lynch           RIC   Fwd           $388,800   1           110   90.5%   111   100.9   111              111

i like lynch given all the G games at home, but we all know about key fwds.
GCS as per another thread here, ??
so leaves me with brayshaw

We don't know how many G games he has now.

[RoughRed]

Cogs or Yeo

Good question... my M5 swings between these two. ..
I am going to review the proposed game schedule and who each plays and where. I have Cogs mainly because he has the captaincy now ... No other reason except that I expect him to respond positively to that

[Carn]

A: McPherson & Houston
Or
B: Laird & Ceglar

[tommy10]

A: McPherson & Houston
Or
B: Laird & Ceglar

Option B, plus let’s u have ruck cover

[SilverLion]

Roberton (D3)+ Noble (D4) + 133k (to be used elsewhere) v Houston (D3) + Greaves + $300. Have Zerk-Thatcher and Starcevich currently on the field aswell.

First option

Player                   Club   Pos            Price   Games   Mins   TOG%   Pts   PPM 100   Ave          1   2

Darcy MacPherson   GCS   Fwd/Mid   $443,800   2           213   86.2%   259   121.6   129.5   132   127
or
Andrew Brayshaw   FRE   Fwd/Mid   $382,800   2           164   70.5%   196   119.5   98           94   102
or
Tom J. Lynch           RIC   Fwd           $388,800   1           110   90.5%   111   100.9   111              111

i like lynch given all the G games at home, but we all know about key fwds.
GCS as per another thread here, ??
so leaves me with brayshaw

DMac :-*

Cogs or Yeo

Cogs

A: McPherson & Houston
Or
B: Laird & Ceglar

A because DMac :-*

[SilverLion]

Cogs + Greenwood + And. Brayshaw vs. Titch + Whitfield + Rookie

[Blues Blues Blues]

Cogs + Greenwood + And. Brayshaw vs. Titch + Whitfield + Rookie

Prob option b for me. Get 2 essentially guaranteed keepers vs 1 keeper and 2 maybes.

1. Laird, Cogs, Naismith, Petracca
Vs
2. Sicily, Viney, Gawn, Cavarra

[Blues Blues Blues]

Another 2:

Laird and Josh Kelly
Vs
Sicily and Neale

Neale v Fyfe

[Samsturmfels]

Another 2:

Laird and Josh Kelly
Vs
Sicily and Neale

Neale v Fyfe

I have gone with Laird and Fyfe.


Walters + defensive rookie (D5) + 39k v Andrew Brayshaw, Noble + 112k left in bank.

[North Melbournes Finest]

I've been wrestling with whether to get SPS in all pre-season. I wish he played one Marsh game so I could at least get one glimpse of his role this year.