2020 Player X v Player y

[Woppa15]

@ D2 Houston or Dawson?

[IntegralX]

@ D2 Houston or Dawson?

Has to be Dawson now with the news about Port/Saints having the standalone Round 11 bye.

[IntegralX]

Noble or Bonar? Looking at getting Dawson in but wondering which one of these expensive rooks is better.

[Colley Dogs]

D1 v Midfield ultra-premium v F4:

Laird + Dangerfield + Ceglar

or

Laird + Macrae + Brayshaw

or

Lloyd + Neale + Dev Smith

[Money Shot]

D1 v Midfield ultra-premium v F4:

Laird + Dangerfield + Ceglar

or

Laird + Macrae + Brayshaw

or

Lloyd + Neale + Dev Smith

Laird, Macrae, Smith

[jvalles69]

D1 v Midfield ultra-premium v F4:

Laird + Dangerfield + Ceglar

or

Laird + Macrae + Brayshaw

or

Lloyd + Neale + Dev Smith

Laird, Macrae, Smith

+1

[Keeper27]

D1 v Midfield ultra-premium v F4:

Laird + Dangerfield + Ceglar

or

Laird + Macrae + Brayshaw

or

Lloyd + Neale + Dev Smith

Laird, Macrae, Smith

+1

[Colley Dogs]

D1 v Midfield ultra-premium v F4:

Laird + Dangerfield + Ceglar

or

Laird + Macrae + Brayshaw

or

Lloyd + Neale + Dev Smith

Laird, Macrae, Smith

+1

Hearing you loud and clear. Thanks

[billnats]

Whitfield, Ceglar & Georgiadis
Or
Ceglar, Steven & D. Smith
Or
Whitfield, Steven/Smith & Bonar

[jbjimmyjb]

Whitfield & Georgiadis
Or
Steven & D. Smith

Whitfield & Georgiadis.
Having both Dev and Steven is too risky imo, personally I'm running with Smith and waiting to see how he goes in Marsh 2.


M4 Bont vs Mitchell?
I've had Bont pencilled in since the first version of my team, but he's probably the mid I like least out of Macrae, Neale, Cripps and Oliver due to his forward time, and Titch looked great tonight.

[billnats]

Whitfield & Georgiadis
Or
Steven & D. Smith

Whitfield & Georgiadis.
Having both Dev and Steven is too risky imo, personally I'm running with Smith and waiting to see how he goes in Marsh 2.

M4 Bont vs Mitchell

I've had Bont pencilled in since the first version of my team, but I don't want any of my starting 5 mids having even a slight chance of being played forward, and Beveridge has a tendency to stick Bont forward when things aren't working.

My other mids are Macrae, Neale, Cripps and Oliver.

I’ve changed mine up a little bit so give me some feedback with new options.

As for yours, I’m currently running with both Bont & Mitchell at that price. Same midfield as yours but Macrae out to allow for the other two. If you definitely want Macrae than Mitchell allows you not to double up on the Bulldogs.

[Colley Dogs]

For M11:

Sharp v Budarick

Who scores better?
Who has better job security?

[SilverLion]

For M11:

Sharp v Budarick

Who scores better?
Who has better job security?

If both are named round 1, pick both. If they're both named and you're forced to only pick one, I'd go Budarick.



JKelly/Danger/Bont/Titch + Dev

vs.

Coniglio + MacPherson

[Colley Dogs]

For M11:

Sharp v Budarick

Who scores better?
Who has better job security?

If both are named round 1, pick both. If they're both named and you're forced to only pick one, I'd go Budarick.



JKelly/Danger/Bont/Titch + Dev

vs.

Coniglio + MacPherson

Thanks for the input.

_______________

Regarding yours...

So difficult to call in isolation. I've been never been on the Dev Smith bandwagon, and have only had him in different versions of my team under duress! Instinctually I opt for Coniglio + MacPherson.

But I'm more interested in how this sits within the larger structure of your team. I've given my thoughts on your team page  :)

[Money Shot]

Dawson v Petracca

I think Dawson is a safe bet for 90 or so but Petracca really has the capability to push 100. In saying that is also more likely to go 85 or less.