2020 Player X v Player y

[Ringo]

Starting this topic for the coming year.

Temember to give reasons why selecting one over the other to assist.

There have been a couple of posts in the archive which I will quote here:

Quote from: elephants on Today at 10:10:39 AM

    Treloar. Tom Mitchell or Jack Macrae

Reply from Crowls
Macrea,  mitchell has to prove he is back to same level.  Treloar not at same level as either.

[Hellopplz]

I'd agree, safe bet is with Macrae after the last two seasons. Mitchell should be cheaper after the year out but does carry more risk and I'm the risk averse type :P.

[dmac07]

Defenders:

Daniel & Laird

Vs

Williams & Sicily 

[RaisyDaisy]

Defenders:

Daniel & Laird

Vs

Williams & Sicily

Daniels and Laird

You know what their roles will be and they rarely miss games

[Corkascrew]

tom mitchell(mid) & greenwood(fwd)
vs
lachie neale(mid) & dev smith(fwd)

[LordSneeze]

tom mitchell(mid) & greenwood(fwd)
vs
lachie neale(mid) & dev smith(fwd)

Mitchell & Greenwood for me.
To be honest though that is 100% a toss up and could go either way.

[dmac07]

tom mitchell(mid) & greenwood(fwd)
vs
lachie neale(mid) & dev smith(fwd)

Mitchell & Greenwood for me.
To be honest though that is 100% a toss up and could go either way.

Close call, id go neale and smith. Though watch how both Mitchell and Smith look pre-season.

[jvalles69]

tom mitchell(mid) & greenwood(fwd)
vs
lachie neale(mid) & dev smith(fwd)

Mitchell & Greenwood for me.
To be honest though that is 100% a toss up and could go either way.

Close call, id go neale and smith. Though watch how both Mitchell and Smith look pre-season.

Neale and Smith and look to upgrade Mitchell in later.  2 x past keepers vs 1.

[frenzy]

Titchell v Danger, so long as Titchell is fit.

[Bones Bombers]

Titchell v Danger, so long as Titchell is fit.

Why take the risk starting Mitchell?
Have another look at Danger’s games played and average each of the last 8 years or so.
He has been very durable and although his scoring has dropped a little each of the last few years he is still right up with the best and has backed it up year after year.

*Please don’t make this year the outlier Danger!

[AaronKirk]

Titchell v Danger, so long as Titchell is fit.

Why take the risk starting Mitchell?
Have another look at Danger’s games played and average each of the last 8 years or so.
He has been very durable and although his scoring has dropped a little each of the last few years he is still right up with the best and has backed it up year after year.

*Please don’t make this year the outlier Danger!

Would IMO be a massive risk to start Titch at $631k. Unless he tears it to shreds in the practise matches I am not touching him.

Will be an upgrade option if he looks the goods in the early stages of the season.

[billnats]

Ash/Anderson & Gawn
V
Yeo/Oliver & NicNat

[crowls]

Titchell v Danger, so long as Titchell is fit.

Why take the risk starting Mitchell?
Have another look at Danger’s games played and average each of the last 8 years or so.
He has been very durable and although his scoring has dropped a little each of the last few years he is still right up with the best and has backed it up year after year.

*Please don’t make this year the outlier Danger!

Would IMO be a massive risk to start Titch at $631k. Unless he tears it to shreds in the practise matches I am not touching him.

Will be an upgrade option if he looks the goods in the early stages of the season.

with you on this ak.   for me it will be danger vs neale and cash will probably be the decider.

[frenzy]

Titchell v Danger, so long as Titchell is fit.

Why take the risk starting Mitchell?
Have another look at Danger’s games played and average each of the last 8 years or so.
He has been very durable and although his scoring has dropped a little each of the last few years he is still right up with the best and has backed it up year after year.

*Please don’t make this year the outlier Danger!

Would IMO be a massive risk to start Titch at $631k. Unless he tears it to shreds in the practise matches I am not touching him.

Will be an upgrade option if he looks the goods in the early stages of the season.

with you on this ak.   for me it will be danger vs neale and cash will probably be the decider.

Thanks boys.

Titchell was the only risky pick I was taking apart from Doc, but everybody will start him. Even Nat Fyfe comes with risk. A full season outta him would be a first.

[IntegralX]

Oliver & Laird vs Coniglio & Lloyd?