2020 Player X v Player y

[RaisyDaisy]

For M11:

Sharp v Budarick

Who scores better?
Who has better job security?

At this stage I doubt you'll get the choice - take anyone we can get! Definitely starting both if they get named, and can't see a scenario where I would only pick one and not the other

JKelly/Danger/Bont/Titch + Dev

vs.

Coniglio + MacPherson

Option 1, easily

Top 5 mid + Dev over a speculative mid and fwd

Dawson v Petracca

I think Dawson is a safe bet for 90 or so but Petracca really has the capability to push 100. In saying that is also more likely to go 85 or less.

I'm just not convinced with Petracca, so I'd go with Dawson - DPP might be helpful too.

[RoughRed]

After the illuminating weekend "not really"

D.Smith v J.Steven v A.Brayshaw

I was pretty sold on what i have seen (and heard) on Brayshaw as a starting F3/F4. Lots of mid time with new coach Longmuir and set to be a possible breakout

Now Dev and Stephen have kicked my possible structure round with some pretty impressive SC scoring today

[tommy10]

Whitfiled, Titch & Ash/Guthrie vs Ceglar, Conigs, Houston

[jvalles69]

After the illuminating weekend "not really"

D.Smith v J.Steven v A.Brayshaw

I was pretty sold on what i have seen (and heard) on Brayshaw as a starting F3/F4. Lots of mid time with new coach Longmuir and set to be a possible breakout

Now Dev and Stephen have kicked my possible structure round with some pretty impressive SC scoring today

All of the above...

[LordSneeze]

Whitfiled, Titch & Ash/Guthrie vs Ceglar, Conigs, Houston

Option 1

Option 2 is just way too risky.

[IntegralX]

Grundy v Gawn? No cop out answers of “both” either please.

[Money Shot]

Grundy v Gawn? No cop out answers of “both” either please.

Both ;)

But out of the two definitely Grundy.

[tommy10]

Whitfiled, Titch & Ash/Guthrie vs Ceglar, Conigs, Houston

Option 1

Option 2 is just way too risky.

Thanks LS, just thinking of having an extra premo in def, but agree with you and am sticking with option 1.

[dylanclements]

Grundy v Gawn?

Gotta be Grundy!

[dmac07]

Houston v Dawson v Crisp

[tommy10]

Houston v Dawson v Crisp

Would say Houston out of the 3 purely because he's tipped to spend more time in the middle this year. In saying that, I haven't got any of them.

Roberton vs Cumming

[jvalles69]

Houston v Dawson v Crisp

Would say Houston out of the 3 purely because he's tipped to spend more time in the middle this year. In saying that, I haven't got any of them.

Roberton vs Cumming

Roberton 200%

[dmac07]

F3/D4

Parish/Dawson & Noble
V
Steven & Roberton

[Woppa15]

@D4 Roberton vs Noble...?
Needing to “cut some fat” in order to fit everyone in and this is one of my options.

[IntegralX]

@D4 Roberton vs Noble...?
Needing to “cut some fat” in order to fit everyone in and this is one of my options.

Roberton's JS is much better than Nobles, but I think it depends on what that extra 45k unlocks for you.