2020 Player X v Player y

[IntegralX]

I know diff positions but Mitch Georgiades or Will Day?

Day no contest. Georgie is could very well be a one week special appearance...I don't see him keeping Westhoff out unless he does something special.

[tkringle]

Simpson or Bennel?

[duff100au]

Got a new one

Crisp v Luke Ryan?

[HoleMeal]

Got a new one

Crisp v Luke Ryan?

I have had Ryan the last 2 seasons. A little but of the ups n downs.
If priced the same I would go Crisp, although prob not as high of a ceiling.

[HoleMeal]

Simpson or Bennel?

Surely Simpson sees more of it with the Cat's outs.

[timtim]

Got a new one

Crisp v Luke Ryan?

I have had Ryan the last 2 seasons. A little but of the ups n downs.
If priced the same I would go Crisp, although prob not as high of a ceiling.

Crisp

Ryan too up and down for me

[Wanderer]

Got a new one

Crisp v Luke Ryan?

I have had Ryan the last 2 seasons. A little but of the ups n downs.
If priced the same I would go Crisp, although prob not as high of a ceiling.

Crisp

Ryan too up and down for me

Agree, Ryan can pump out a few low scores from time to time.

[SilverLion]

Sicily + Whitfield vs. Doedee + Taylor Adams

Sicily BE 28, Whitfield BE 67, Doedee BE 28, Adams BE 108
You can wait on Adams because his price won't go up too much.
Sicily and Whitfield most likely to be top 6 in their positions and their price will go up.
The other option is to go Whitfield and Doedee and save 90k, then get Sicily after his round 10 bye.

Ended up going Sicily and Whitfield.

First bit of good luck I've had all year.

[Wanderer]

Sicily + Whitfield vs. Doedee + Taylor Adams

Sicily BE 28, Whitfield BE 67, Doedee BE 28, Adams BE 108
You can wait on Adams because his price won't go up too much.
Sicily and Whitfield most likely to be top 6 in their positions and their price will go up.
The other option is to go Whitfield and Doedee and save 90k, then get Sicily after his round 10 bye.

Ended up going Sicily and Whitfield.

First bit of good luck I've had all year.

It was the smartest move, getting two of the best top 6 in their respective positions and at low BE's. Well done!

[IntegralX]

Ridley vs Daniel

Parker vs Gaff vs Zerrett

[Blues Blues Blues]

Ridley vs Daniel

Parker vs Gaff vs Zerrett

Prob Daniel > Ridley (just). I have Ridley and very happy but Daniel does have potential tonget a lot of the ball
Gaff > Parker > Zerrett

[Blues Blues Blues]

Treloar vs Macrae vs Josh Kelly
Greene vs Bailey Smith (worth the extra $70k)?

[North Melbournes Finest]

Lloyd 590k - 115 ave
Haynes 550k - 111 ave
Ridley 520k - 110 ave
Saad 490k - 102ave

Genuinely torn up on this one. I'd love to bring in Lloyd, but for that much more than Haynes and Ridley is he worth spending all that extra money?

[Wanderer]

Lloyd 590k - 115 ave
Haynes 550k - 111 ave
Ridley 520k - 110 ave
Saad 490k - 102ave

Genuinely torn up on this one. I'd love to bring in Lloyd, but for that much more than Haynes and Ridley is he worth spending all that extra money?

You have to get Lloyd at some stage, but maybe wait until after his round 11 bye.
With Haynes, not sure how Zach Williams will impact him, and he also has a bye in round 11.
Ridley and Saad both have the benefit of no byes, but Ridley is better IMO. He has gone under 100 twice and his lowest score has been 92. Saad's lowest score has been 80.

[Wanderer]

Treloar vs Macrae vs Josh Kelly
Greene vs Bailey Smith (worth the extra $70k)?

Macrae easily due to durability, then Kelly, Treloar. I think Treloar might be managed at some point given condensed schedule. Kelly also has the bye in round 11.

Bailey Smith a no-brainer over Toby Greene. The $70k savings is huge and Toby misses way too many games.