The Rookies Thread 2020

[PowerBug]

Next week might have too many choices for bubble boys. What order would you rank these guys. couldn't find the poll option unless I started a new thread.

Added a poll to the current thread :)

Two votes per user, ability to change vote as well if you change your mind :o

[IntegralX]

Rankine won’t kick 3 goals every week to get 110 off 12 touches, still thinking Simpson and Day.

[shaker]

Rankine won’t kick 3 goals every week to get 110 off 12 touches, still thinking Simpson and Day.

Rankine was always touted as unbelievable talent it's only injuries that have prevented us seeing it take 40 points out for the 3 goals still a good score Clarkson was grumbling about his defence after the match so can't say Day's JS is very high unlike Rankine's.

[JBs-Hawks]

Rankine won’t kick 3 goals every week to get 110 off 12 touches, still thinking Simpson and Day.

Rankine was always touted as unbelievable talent it's only injuries that have prevented us seeing it take 40 points out for the 3 goals still a good score Clarkson was grumbling about his defence after the match so can't say Day's JS is very high unlike Rankine's.

Day was our 2nd best player after Sicily

[shaker]

Rankine won’t kick 3 goals every week to get 110 off 12 touches, still thinking Simpson and Day.

Rankine was always touted as unbelievable talent it's only injuries that have prevented us seeing it take 40 points out for the 3 goals still a good score Clarkson was grumbling about his defence after the match so can't say Day's JS is very high unlike Rankine's.

Day was our 2nd best player after Sicily

Yeah he played good but I don't trust Clarko Rankine might score a 50 or 60 this week but his JS is good.

[tkringle]

Anyone else jump on Aarts?

[justaverage]

Anyone else jump on Aarts?

:-[

[Wanderer]

Anyone else jump on Aarts?

Lets hope he gets another game to redeem himself.

[RaisyDaisy]

Passed on him, but for those who grabbed him don't be too worried - he should get more games

Simpson and Rankine for me this week

[Rusty00]

Only issue with Day and Simpson is Clarko and Scott who seeem to have no trouble dropping kids, Remember Constable from last year,  A little hard with rookies this year with price rises after 2 games.
In saying that still thinking of getting both for cash.

Clarko also said that McEvoy was staying down back and Ceglar was No1 ruck that has changed in the last 2 games ask the people that got Ceglar believing him a 43 and a 53 , Clarko was angry with his defence so steering clear of Day he may play again next week but think his JS is shaky.

My take is with Patton injured early, we were too short down forward, meaning McEvoy needed to switch to the forward line. TOB was playing second ruck, however if we kept doing that it would've meant McEvoy and Ceglar both in the forward line, further decreasing our ability to lock the ball in our forward line. Therefore McEvoy and Ceglar started switching between ruck/forward.

I didn't see the game last week, however with Mitch Lewis getting injured, it could've been the same scenario (or maybe it's just wishful thinking as I own Ceglar.....).

Day played Scrimshaw's role on Friday night, so his JS could depend on how long Scrimshaw is out for as he will come straight back in when fit.

[shaker]

Only issue with Day and Simpson is Clarko and Scott who seeem to have no trouble dropping kids, Remember Constable from last year,  A little hard with rookies this year with price rises after 2 games.
In saying that still thinking of getting both for cash.

Clarko also said that McEvoy was staying down back and Ceglar was No1 ruck that has changed in the last 2 games ask the people that got Ceglar believing him a 43 and a 53 , Clarko was angry with his defence so steering clear of Day he may play again next week but think his JS is shaky.

My take is with Patton injured early, we were too short down forward, meaning McEvoy needed to switch to the forward line. TOB was playing second ruck, however if we kept doing that it would've meant McEvoy and Ceglar both in the forward line, further decreasing our ability to lock the ball in our forward line. Therefore McEvoy and Ceglar started switching between ruck/forward.

I didn't see the game last week, however with Mitch Lewis getting injured, it could've been the same scenario (or maybe it's just wishful thinking as I own Ceglar.....).

Day played Scrimshaw's role on Friday night, so his JS could depend on how long Scrimshaw is out for as he will come straight back in when fit.

In R5 against GWS there was one passage of play where McEvoy's opponent highlighted he is not very agile and resulted in an easy goal the move was made after that so maybe the experiment is over ? time will tell.

[Rusty00]

Only issue with Day and Simpson is Clarko and Scott who seeem to have no trouble dropping kids, Remember Constable from last year,  A little hard with rookies this year with price rises after 2 games.
In saying that still thinking of getting both for cash.

Clarko also said that McEvoy was staying down back and Ceglar was No1 ruck that has changed in the last 2 games ask the people that got Ceglar believing him a 43 and a 53 , Clarko was angry with his defence so steering clear of Day he may play again next week but think his JS is shaky.

My take is with Patton injured early, we were too short down forward, meaning McEvoy needed to switch to the forward line. TOB was playing second ruck, however if we kept doing that it would've meant McEvoy and Ceglar both in the forward line, further decreasing our ability to lock the ball in our forward line. Therefore McEvoy and Ceglar started switching between ruck/forward.

I didn't see the game last week, however with Mitch Lewis getting injured, it could've been the same scenario (or maybe it's just wishful thinking as I own Ceglar.....).

Day played Scrimshaw's role on Friday night, so his JS could depend on how long Scrimshaw is out for as he will come straight back in when fit.

In R5 against GWS there was one passage of play where McEvoy's opponent highlighted he is not very agile and resulted in an easy goal the move was made after that so maybe the experiment is over ? time will tell.

Yeah, I saw that. He also took 3-4 intercept marks in defence in the first quarter against Collingwood before being moved.

Hawks aren't exactly firing, so there will be changes, and who knows what Clarko has in mind.

[Ingram]

Have to pass on Simpson in favour of bringing Gawn in. Have Serong so I'll persist with him for now.

[frenzy]

Surely McInerney is back this week now that JPK and Heeney are injured.  :o

[HoleMeal]

Surely McInerney is back this week now that JPK and Heeney are injured.  :o

Surely he is.