The Rookies Thread 2020

[IntegralX]

Crap. Not sure if i should replace BJ Williams and Robertson or just keep them hoping they play next week..

I'm leaning towards holding onto Williams...I don't think Brown has any JS whatsoever, whilst I believe Williams could be back as soon as next week. Hickey (and Vardy) showed me nothing at all in preseason to show that they're better than Williams...

[tkringle]

food for thought, if we go a tyler brown/mcinerney with starcevich down back, we have the option to trade brown/mcinerney down after one price rise to either williams or robertson if one gets named round 2.

Of course this relies on tyler brown getting a price rise before treloar comes back.

AFL Injury list has Treloar 1-2 weeks away. Thinking they will go at least 2 given his hamstring issues last year. Might be worthwhile going Brown

[jfitty]

On Bailey Williams via Eagles Twitter:

"Williams is tracking back from a hamstring :)"

I might hold and hope he comes in next week or the one after.. Not enough cash to get McAsey, and not restructuring now!

[dmac07]

Im committed to starting a 0 in defense now.. question is, Gould or Williams?

[Mat0369]

I'm moving Williams to R3

[tkringle]

I'm moving Williams to R3

Who are you bringing in at D7 or 8 for him?

[Mat0369]

I moved my premos around and ended up bringing in Sicily but had to field Cavarra. That half backfired

[SilverLion]

Think I'm copping BJWilliams at D8, don't trust Starcevich to hold his spot, and can't find the funds to get him anyways.

If he comes out and gets 100, I'll trade him in next week though :))

[whynot102]

Cavara disappointing and on field

[RoughRed]

Cavara disappointing and on field

+1

[Mat0369]

While Cavarra on field hurts, he should probably hold his spot and get a better crack at it next week.  The Dogs had only 22 inside 50's and were awful.

[enzedder]

Going with...
D - Zerk Thatcher, Brander, Noble (Williams, Starcevich)
M - Rowell, Green, Pickett (McInenery, Budarick, Robertson)
R - (Xerri)
F - Taylor (Georgiades, King)

Hate the look of the mid bench.

[Wanderer]

While Cavarra on field hurts, he should probably hold his spot and get a better crack at it next week.  The Dogs had only 22 inside 50's and were awful.

He had no chance to score even a half decent score the way that game was played last night. I wouldn't write him off just yet.

[Mat0369]

F'ing McAsey

[RaisyDaisy]

F'ing McAsey

Thankfully I put him on the bench, but geez the rookie situation is looking bleak

The saving grace is that most of us are in the same position so we're all copping it