WXV Trade Confabulation 2019

[kilbluff1985]

also n12 is leading offer for pendles

if anyone wants to try and beat it with an earlier pick

would consider a good young forward we like to

[Purple 77]

Two teams left to vote:
- Mexico City
- Cairo

The following have received either 0 or 1 vote, and will thus auto-pass (haven't checked on-traded elements though):

Trade 1
Dublin trade: Jarrod Cameron
PNL trade: Tom Campbell + Pick 57

Trade 2
Cape Town trade: Touk Miller + Jack Petrucelle
London trade: Luke Shuey + Sam Gray

Trade 3
New York trade: Ed Phillips
Beijing trade: Sam Switkowski

Trade 4
Dublin trade: Pick 59
Toronto trade: Ben McKay

Trade 5
Cairo trade: Will Hayes
Cairo receive: Alex Neal-Bullen

Cape Town trade: Alex Neal-Bullen
Cape Town receive: Mabior Chol

Toronto trade: Mabior Chol
Toronto receive: Will Hayes

Trade 7
Dublin trade: Elliot Himmelberg, Pick 41 + Pick 77
Dublin receive: Brandon Starcevich, Pick 52 + Pick 58

Berlin trade: Brandon Starcevich + Pick 52
Berlin receive: Pick 40 + Pick 41

New York trade: Pick 40 + Pick 58
New York receive: Elliot Himmelberg + Pick 77

Trade 8
New York trade: Martin Frederick
Tokyo trade: Zac Smith

Trade 9
Berlin trade: Nat Fyfe, Jack Viney, Oskar Baker + Pick 41
Rio de Janeiro trade: Patrick Cripps + Pick 33

Trade 11
Berlin trade: Michael Walters, Pick 15, Pick 33 + Pick 34
Tokyo trade: Bayley Fritsch, Sam Powell-Pepper, Will Hoskin-Elliott + Pick 7

Trade 13
New York trade: Isaac Heeney, Alex Sexton + Pick 22
Toronto trade: Jacob Hopper, James Harmes + Thomas Cole

Trade 14
New York trade: Jacob Hopper + Pick 3
Buenos Aires trade: Caleb Daniel + Tom Doedee

Trade 15
Berlin trade: Michael Hibberd
Toronto trade: Allen Christensen

Trade 16
New York trade: Brodie Smith + Pick 77
Berlin trade: Pick 7 + Pick 40



In dispute

Trade 6
Toronto trade: Brayden Fiorini, Robbie Fox + Pick 17 
New Delhi trade: Jack Darling, Dan Hannebery + Pick 55

Trade 12
Rio de Janeiro trade: Jaeger O'Meara + Pick 51
Toronto trade: Matthew Kreuzer, Andrew Phillips + Pick 36



Blocked (and will have to be re-posted)

Trade 10
PNL trade: Nicholas Shipley, Pick 2 + Pick 21
New Delhi trade: Steele Sidebottom, Shane Savage + Robbie Gray

[iZander]

Looking for a young forward, hit me up for trade talks!

[Purple 77]

Annddd that's all the votes!

All trades (except that blocked one) auto-pass!

I'll update the threads probably on Thursday

[iZander]

Defenders.
On the Market: Jamie Macmillan, Jimmy Webster, Daniel Talia,, Tom Clurey, Jayden Hunt, Jesse Joyce, Michael Hartley, Conor Glass, Jacob Heron (FWD), Jordan Butts (FWD), Rory Thompson
Could be Moved:
Probably Staying: Riley Bonner, Nicholas Coffield, Jack Scrimshaw


Mids.
On the Market: David Armitage (FWD), Lochie O'Brien
Could be Moved: Trent Dumont
Probably Staying: Luke Parker, Bryce Gibbs
Not going anywhere Ollie Wines, Jarrod Berry, Andrew Brayshaw, Joe Atley, Oliver Florent, Jacob Hopper

Rucks.
On the Market.: Keegan Brooksby
Could be Moved:
Probably Staying: Sam Jacobs, Tom Nicholls, Reilly O'Brien,

Fwds.
On the Market: Will Hayward, Aiden Bonar (MID), Shaun Atley, Noah Gown, Nathan Kreuger, Cam Polson, Zach Sproule (MID), Matthew Owies (MID), Guy Walker (DEF), Callum Brown
Could be Moved:  Cameron Rayner, Brayden Crossley
Probably Staying: Darcy Parish (MID), Adam Cerra

Picks
3,6,23,25,43,79 - n3 probably the only 1 id rather keep, otherwise also on the market

[Holz]

Matt Crouch is maybe on the table.

Im looking for a young starter mid and amother mid (can be older) or a starter upgrade

[Jroo]

Getting a bit of intetest in some of my mids. Willing to listen to offers for these guys

Lachie Hunter, Luke Dunstan, Anthony Miles, Brad Hill, Luke Davies-Uniacke, Jack Graham, Matt Guelfi, George Horlin-Smith

[meow meow]

We'll give you Crouch for Hunter and LDU.

[Purple 77]

Lists and Draft Order updated

Likewise 2019 WXV Trade Centre

[GoLions]

For everyone that has asked about N9 previously, could be gone today / this weekend.

[iZander]

Considering a few offers for Trent Dumont

Also had a few discussions about Jamie Macmillan if anyone is interested?

[Purple 77]

Two teams left to vote:
- Cape Town
- PNL



The following are still in dispute:

Trade 10
PNL trade: Nicholas Shipley, Pick 2 + Pick 21
New Delhi trade: Steele Sidebottom, Shane Savage + Robbie Gray

Trade 18
Pacific trade: Peter Ladhams, Billy Frampton, Brayden Ham, Ethan Hughes + Pick 47
Tokyo trade: Harry Perryman, Tom McCartin, Pick 15 + Pick 62

Trade 21
Christchurch trade: Connor McFadyen, Pick 1, Pick 20 + Pick 38
Seoul trade: Brandon Parfitt, Cameron Zurhaar, Brandon Matera, Cameron McCarthy + Pick 11



The following have received 1 or 0 votes, and will thus auto-pass:

Trade 17
Dublin trade: Pick 23
Buenos Aires trade: Cale Hooker + Pick 61

Trade 19
London trade: Josh Bruce
New Delhi trade: Jack Newnes



The following has so far received 8 votes, and will thus auto-fail:

Trade 20
Beijing trade: Darcy MacPherson
New Delhi trade: Scott Pendlebury


I will send the reasons to Beijing & New Delhi once everyone has voted. In the meantime, the unanimous feeling is that Pendlebury is worth more than the still unproven MacPherson

[Purple 77]

This trade has now auto-passed

Trade 10
PNL trade: Nicholas Shipley, Pick 2 + Pick 21
New Delhi trade: Steele Sidebottom, Shane Savage + Robbie Gray



The other two will be judged in due course.

[Purple 77]

Trade 18
Pacific trade: Peter Ladhams, Billy Frampton, Brayden Ham, Ethan Hughes + Pick 47
Tokyo trade: Harry Perryman, Tom McCartin, Pick 15 + Pick 62
Votes: 5
Coaches comments: A strong feeling Ladhams is approximately worth Perryman, and that Pick 15 is an overpay for the remaining 4 Pacific components, let alone McCartin and Pick 62.
Admin comments: It's hard to disagree with these coaches tbh. But I've slept on it, and decided I'm more uneasy about overturning it than I am about letting it pass. I exercise the power to overturn when I'm super confident, and I'm not that on this one, despite my efforts. At the end of the day, this trade has landed on 5 votes which is a pass, and there is a ruck premium to be paid. I think you could make the argument that
McCartin = Hughes
Perryman + 15 = Ladhams + Pick 30ish
Pick 30ish + 62 = Pick 47, Ham and Frampton (who is OOC)
That makes jussst enough sense for me to leave alone.
Verdict: PASS

Trade 21
Christchurch trade: Connor McFadyen, Pick 1, Pick 20 + Pick 38
Seoul trade: Brandon Parfitt, Cameron Zurhaar, Brandon Matera, Cameron McCarthy + Pick 11
Votes:  6
Coaches comments:  Most took issue with Christchurch paying reasonable draft picks for what is essentially a cap dump from Seoul who would otherwise have to delist.
Admin comments:  Landing on 6 votes, the trade is rejected with me having the power to overturn. I don't disagree with the coaches enough to overturn this one. I also think given the Saints position (with absolutely no intentions of doubting Koops ability to transform the list), I'll probably tend to put an onus on the other team to give more in these line-ball decisions. Seoul has cap to dump and is in a comfortable position. I don't think it's too unreasonable, given the coaches comments, to require them to add more. I feel like a solution here could be to replace one or both of Matera & McCarthy with a player that carries more cap and averages just that little bit more to actually provide SOME use to Christchurch.
Verdict: REJECTED



I'll PM coaches the neg reasons tomorrow (apologies for delay... but I'm le tired)

[Koop]

Okay, well I expect 6 trade offers in the next 24 hours. All of those offers must be in my cap favour by almost 600k or over, as well as offer me appropriate future compensation and multiplication of assets.

I'm waiting. :)