Week 8 Trades

[Hazza09]

If Hately is named would it be a waste to go Scott - Hately?

Or is it more profitable to go Pettrutelle - Corbett?

With Corbett i see a very slow burn happening, i dont see him going 80+ and with Burgess and Scott sitting at M11 and D8 as dead wood i dont know if im interested in having Corbett possibly doing the same at F7.

[Rusty00]

If Hately is named would it be a waste to go Scott - Hately?

Or is it more profitable to go Pettrutelle - Corbett?

With Corbett i see a very slow burn happening, i dont see him going 80+ and with Burgess and Scott sitting at M11 and D8 as dead wood i dont know if im interested in having Corbett possibly doing the same at F7.

IMO it's a waste. Round 3-4 would have been ok as a "correctional trade", however I think you need to be making money from trades now to fund upgrades. (If you've only used a few trades and are playing predominantly for league then it may be ok). Do you not have any other fattened rookies you could trade?

I'm not convinced with Corbett as isn't he essentially playing the exact role that Burgess is playing? Tall forward in a Suns team that is going to get beat most weeks.

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm not convinced with Corbett as isn't he essentially playing the exact role that Burgess is playing? Tall forward in a Suns team that is going to get beat most weeks.

Yep, but he is a much better player than Burgess

I feel like a lot of people need a bit of a reality check - outside of Drew (who isn't even a fwd and Baker who cost a lot more) every forward rookie has been rubbish, and it shouldn't be surprising

Petruccelle has made 150k profit which is fantastic for a rookie, so to be able to cash that in and bring in Corbett who has just as good JS and will score similar, is an absolute no brainer for me

People need to reduce their expectations - 55+ from a fwd rookie with solid JS is very valuable, and shouldn't be sneezed at

[HappyDEZ]

I'm not convinced with Corbett as isn't he essentially playing the exact role that Burgess is playing? Tall forward in a Suns team that is going to get beat most weeks.

Yep, but he is a much better player than Burgess

I feel like a lot of people need a bit of a reality check - outside of Drew (who isn't even a fwd and Baker who cost a lot more) every forward rookie has been rubbish, and it shouldn't be surprising

Petruccelle has made 150k profit which is fantastic for a rookie, so to be able to cash that in and bring in Corbett who has just as good JS and will score similar, is an absolute no brainer for me

People need to reduce their expectations - 55+ from a fwd rookie with solid JS is very valuable, and shouldn't be sneezed at

& Miers who most of us missed unfortunately.

[Judd Magic]

Butters to Hately
Scrimshaw to Lloyd

Hopefully Hately keeps his spot leaves me with 247k after those trades

Kelly and Whitfield both to return

Hately's chances would have to be very slim

[batt]

Really tempted by Guthrie

The more I think about my trades this week, the less I think Answerth is a must.  Week by week proposition and only drafted last year.

Corbett on the other hand... as has been said.... can't see any forward rookies anywhere.

[enzedder]

Rookies are the ones to get this week for sure.
Double downgrade this week. Double upgrade next week.
Corbett as a fwd rookie has come at a great time. Nice bye too.

[sammy123]

Butters to Hately
Scrimshaw to Lloyd

Hopefully Hately keeps his spot leaves me with 247k after those trades

Kelly and Whitfield both to return

Hately's chances would have to be very slim

Yeah cant see him being named but if named i will probably grab him

[justaverage]

Butters to Hately
Scrimshaw to Lloyd

Hopefully Hately keeps his spot leaves me with 247k after those trades

Kelly and Whitfield both to return

Hately's chances would have to be very slim

Yeah cant see him being named but if named i will probably grab him

Gotta hate that, maybe Stocker keeps his spot and improves

[kilbluff1985]

Drew/Clark out Answerth/Corbett in

next week

Wilkie/Duur out 2 guns in

[AaronKirk]

Petrucelle to Corbett
Drew to Cameron

Boak, Dangerfield, Heeney, Kelly, Daniel and Cameron on field as forwards.

[YoungGun]

Gibbons to Answerth
Walsh to Fyfe 370k left

Or

Ridley to Answerth
Gibbons to Fyfe 220k left

Or

Gibbons to Answerth
Constable to Fyfe 220k left

Hoping constable somehow gets back into the team and will feel semi comfortable punting Walsh to guarantee Lloyd in next week and an acheivable upgrade after that

[js19]

Petrucelle to Corbett
Drew to Cameron

Boak, Dangerfield, Heeney, Kelly, Daniel and Cameron on field as forwards.

That’s a cracking fwd line at this stage! Well done

[Sabretooth Tigers]

::)

Wilkie to Answerth  and believe it or not, almost with some sort of confidence, and a large slice of insanity, Petruccelli to Toby Greene.
Reasons for Toby as stated in how many trades. I am scarily confident about this trade.

:D

Total change of plans.   J Clarke to Answerth   Libba to Bontempelli.  Can grab Greene later.

[Big Mac]

Considering Libba to Tmac via Drew