Round 5 Trades

[bkimm32]

well, after all the commotion all week i reckon i'll go into round 5 without a trade lol

with rotham out i'm happy to hold onto setterfield, parker is playing and should still make cash, same with scott and butterss, and its probably not worth it to trade sweet to ROB... i'll pass on stack and wait for ross, i think!

holding.

I'm gonna do the Sweet to O'Brien trade. Looping Butters with Setterfield, if Butters fails, I might trade Setterfield to Stack.

Yeah I've changed my tune and pulled the trigger on it

My thoughts- I have only used 1 trade so can afford another rookie correction... plus the insurance if gawn or Grundy go down is worth it's weight in gold.

[DaveElNacho]

Haven't needed to make any trades yet. Worth going Zac Clarke to ROB?

[bkimm32]

Haven't needed to make any trades yet. Worth going Zac Clarke to ROB?

I believe so

[AaronKirk]

Butters to Ross and Parker to Daniel is what I have done this week

[EA100]

Have 270k already in the bank already. Just tossing up with a few ideas still..

Setters to ROB via Bines into the forward line then move Drew into the midfield and upgrade Butters to a prem forward for 560k or less.. which gives me a forward line of Danger, Heeney, Dunkley, PREM FORWARD, Moore, Petruccelle (Balta & Bines). That way i could have maybe 100k left over + another downgrade to Ross from Drew and then upgrade somewhere else.

[Mat0369]

That fact you have to field one of Balta or Petruccelle is a huge worry.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Thinking the following:

Constable to Ross
Sheed to Whitfield (via Dursma to mids)

Problem is:
- Constable still plenty of cash to make
- I only brought Sheed in last week (regretted as soon as I pressed confirm trade)

[jfitty]

Thinking Setterfield > O'Brien makes sense.. Just means I have to live with Bines at F8 for a bit!

By the time Setterfield comes back, O'Brien would have made 120k+. Not the most ideal trade in terms of cash generation, but I've only used 1 trade so far so can mark it off as a rookie correction almost.

[tor01doc]

Thinking the following:

Constable to Ross
Sheed to Whitfield (via Dursma to mids)

Problem is:
- Constable still plenty of cash to make
- I only brought Sheed in last week (regretted as soon as I pressed confirm trade)

Don’t

[North Melbournes Finest]

I've been so confused on who I should trade between Bines/Setterfield/Balta for O'Brien but I think I'll do Bines. At least the other two COULD still generate some cash.

[Bully]

I've been so confused on who I should trade between Bines/Setterfield/Balta for O'Brien but I think I'll do Bines. At least the other two COULD still generate some cash.

But will cost you an extra trade to get O'Brien out of the R3 position.

[North Melbournes Finest]

Devon Smith > Heeney (bringing him back jesus) / Marshall / Billings / Daniel

Which one should I bring in? Heeney is obviously the best player there, but I already traded him out and my pride will take a bit of a knock haha. I really like Marshall, would be saving a tonne of cash and have a nice POD (question marks if he will be the number one ruck all year?). Billings has been really consistent, and I think that his scoring could have been higher, he's been getting plenty of it. Daniel is just thrown in there, I don't think I'd do it.

[RoughRed]

Devon Smith > Heeney (bringing him back jesus) / Marshall / Billings / Daniel

Which one should I bring in? Heeney is obviously the best player there, but I already traded him out and my pride will take a bit of a knock haha. I really like Marshall, would be saving a tonne of cash and have a nice POD (question marks if he will be the number one ruck all year?). Billings has been really consistent, and I think that his scoring could have been higher, he's been getting plenty of it. Daniel is just thrown in there, I don't think I'd do it.

You realise that it is only Good Friday ... you are a bit early   ::)

[Locinator]

Devon Smith > Heeney (bringing him back jesus) / Marshall / Billings / Daniel

Which one should I bring in? Heeney is obviously the best player there, but I already traded him out and my pride will take a bit of a knock haha. I really like Marshall, would be saving a tonne of cash and have a nice POD (question marks if he will be the number one ruck all year?). Billings has been really consistent, and I think that his scoring could have been higher, he's been getting plenty of it. Daniel is just thrown in there, I don't think I'd do it.

Best move is to trade in the player you think will score the most out of the 4. If thats Heeney to you, ignore your pride and get him in

[_wato]

Devon Smith > Heeney (bringing him back jesus) / Marshall / Billings / Daniel

Which one should I bring in? Heeney is obviously the best player there, but I already traded him out and my pride will take a bit of a knock haha. I really like Marshall, would be saving a tonne of cash and have a nice POD (question marks if he will be the number one ruck all year?). Billings has been really consistent, and I think that his scoring could have been higher, he's been getting plenty of it. Daniel is just thrown in there, I don't think I'd do it.

Best move is to trade in the player you think will score the most out of the 4. If thats Heeney to you, ignore your pride and get him in

Absolutely. Dunno about Caleb Daniel being 'thrown in there' though. Guy looks a genuine chance at top 6.