Round 5 Trades

[LaHug]

whats the reason everyone is sleeping on Rotham?

poor JS?

Yep, might not even be named this week which would be good for down the track.

If he is named, I'm getting him in. Will make good coin if he stays on the park. Have Hore already so will be D7 at worst. If he doesn't play, can loophole him. If Hore/Rotham gets dropped, then will upgrade one of them. ROB is locked either way.

But would you get him over Stack?

Pick two of: ROB, Stack, Hore, Rotham...

[no eye deer]

whats the reason everyone is sleeping on Rotham?

poor JS?

Yep, might not even be named this week which would be good for down the track.

If he is named, I'm getting him in. Will make good coin if he stays on the park. Have Hore already so will be D7 at worst. If he doesn't play, can loophole him. If Hore/Rotham gets dropped, then will upgrade one of them. ROB is locked either way.

But would you get him over Stack?

Pick two of: ROB, Stack, Hore, Rotham...

ROB and Hore. That’s what I’ll do if I for some stupid reason decide to give Greene another week.

[tommy10]

whats the reason everyone is sleeping on Rotham?

poor JS?

Yep, might not even be named this week which would be good for down the track.

If he is named, I'm getting him in. Will make good coin if he stays on the park. Have Hore already so will be D7 at worst. If he doesn't play, can loophole him. If Hore/Rotham gets dropped, then will upgrade one of them. ROB is locked either way.

But would you get him over Stack?

Pick two of: ROB, Stack, Hore, Rotham...

Think Butters who's my M8 will outscore Stack this week. Plus I'm getting in Ross next week. Also allows me to have Drew as F6 with Moore moving fwd.

ROB and Hore LH.

[IntegralX]

It looks like Rotham is going to get dropped for Jetta, but I can still do Butters/Cousins to Marshall/O'Brien. It means I'm forced into Petrucelle this week though.

[tyhwu]

Just wondering if rocky is a must and is cousins still a hold even though he has only made me 77k?

Could do butters > stack and then cousins > rocky, helps upgrade cousins to a 'premo', although that really depends if rocky is just a stepping stone or if he will finish in the top 8.

Seems to be a bit of a waste to start cousins only to have him make me so little, but hard to pass up the points that rocky is putting out.

[tor01doc]

So I have the top two rucks already, and only 28 trades left for the rest of the season, tell me why I should get rid of one.

Just seems ludicrous.

Get O’Brien for R3 cash if that’s what you need but there are always rookies coming through.

[YoungGun]

What information has come about for people to be so confident about Rotham being dropped?

Jetta was always coming back this week wasn't he, and nobody seemed hugely concerned by that earlier this week?

If Rotham named I'll roll the dice. Clark D7 Hore D8 atm, ditch Parker who's given me two 30's coverimg flowering Greene and swing Moore up.

[tkringle]

What information has come about for people to be so confident about Rotham being dropped?

Jetta was always coming back this week wasn't he, and nobody seemed hugely concerned by that earlier this week?

If Rotham named I'll roll the dice. Clark D7 Hore D8 atm, ditch Parker who's given me two 30's coverimg flowering Greene and swing Moore up.

Jetta was a late out last week with Rotham coming in as the emergency

[tkringle]

What information has come about for people to be so confident about Rotham being dropped?

Jetta was always coming back this week wasn't he, and nobody seemed hugely concerned by that earlier this week?

If Rotham named I'll roll the dice. Clark D7 Hore D8 atm, ditch Parker who's given me two 30's coverimg flowering Greene and swing Moore up.

Jetta was a late out last week with Rotham coming in as the emergency

Rotham dropped - confirmed

[bkimm32]

well, after all the commotion all week i reckon i'll go into round 5 without a trade lol

with rotham out i'm happy to hold onto setterfield, parker is playing and should still make cash, same with scott and butterss, and its probably not worth it to trade sweet to ROB... i'll pass on stack and wait for ross, i think!

holding.

[Mat0369]

I think Alabaskis to O'Brien for some ruck coverage is worth the trade. That leaves me with bringing in either Hore or Stack.

My rookies are below

Collins - Cash to make, holding
Rozee - See Collins
Clark/Scrimshaw/Duursma - See above

So defenders I'd rather hold for a few weeks, if anything I can move Rozee forward of Duursma into my mid line if need be

Walsh - Not trading since he looks to be hitting his stride
Cousins - Probably good for a fortnight and can become Hately
Constable - Holding since he still has cash to make
Butters - Poor score last week, has been excellent prior to that and could make more cash
Gibbons - Not enough cash earned in sideways trade
Scott - Same as Gibbons
Drew - Still has cash to make
Setters - Not enough cash made in trade
Parker - High BE but could see a nice boost with an 80 this week, probably between him and Butters

Looking at that Butters probably makes the most sense. I could go Butters>Hore using Setters and Rozee and then turn Alabaskis into O'Brien

[Bully]

I think Alabaskis to O'Brien for some ruck coverage is worth the trade. That leaves me with bringing in either Hore or Stack.

My rookies are below

Collins - Cash to make, holding
Rozee - See Collins
Clark/Scrimshaw/Duursma - See above

So defenders I'd rather hold for a few weeks, if anything I can move Rozee forward of Duursma into my mid line if need be

Walsh - Not trading since he looks to be hitting his stride
Cousins - Probably good for a fortnight and can become Hately
Constable - Holding since he still has cash to make
Butters - Poor score last week, has been excellent prior to that and could make more cash
Gibbons - Not enough cash earned in sideways trade
Scott - Same as Gibbons
Drew - Still has cash to make
Setters - Not enough cash made in trade
Parker - High BE but could see a nice boost with an 80 this week, probably between him and Butters

Looking at that Butters probably makes the most sense. I could go Butters>Hore using Setters and Rozee and then turn Alabaskis into O'Brien

Just make sure Parker is playing first.

[Goosey]

well, after all the commotion all week i reckon i'll go into round 5 without a trade lol

with rotham out i'm happy to hold onto setterfield, parker is playing and should still make cash, same with scott and butterss, and its probably not worth it to trade sweet to ROB... i'll pass on stack and wait for ross, i think!

holding.

I'm gonna do the Sweet to O'Brien trade. Looping Butters with Setterfield, if Butters fails, I might trade Setterfield to Stack.

[jbjimmyjb]

Looking like Setterfield > ROB (via Bines) will be my only trade this week.
Already have Hore, and there is no one suitable to trade out for Stack, unless I was to ditch Clark for him, but he has a BE of 15.

[Mat0369]

Just make sure Parker is playing first.

No difference, he will be on my bench with Setters on my mid bench. Drew and Rozee would be my two rookies on the field in my forward line