Round 5 Trades

[RaisyDaisy]

Feeling good, figured out my trades

Parker and Setters out, ROB and Hore in

Next week Atkins/Scott to Ross and Clark/Burgess to prem forward which will only leave Drew as only fwd rookie on field

Means I need to field Petrucelle this week which sucks, but short term pain for long term gain

[enzedder]

opt 1 parker>marshall,  butters>rotham    duursma to mids.     
opt 2 sheed>lloyd goldstein>mumford

option 3 sheed>lloyd  goldy>rob
option4  goldstein>ROB  burgess>lloyd   leaves setters, petroljelly parker as f6-f8

Rule out option 1 mate unless you're happy to have Rotham sit at D8. Everything I've read says here, on Twitter and elsewhere says he's a poor option.
Not sure as to what is the best of the other options.
Sheed looks set to score as he has previously. Mumford a good option but ROB looks rock solid for 200k profit now as he should play at least 4 or 5 games minimum.
Option 3 perhaps.

[tkringle]

Feeling good, figured out my trades

Parker and Setters out, ROB and Hore in

Next week Atkins/Scott to Ross and Clark/Burgess to prem forward which will only leave Drew as only fwd rookie on field

Means I need to field Petrucelle this week which sucks, but short term pain for long term gain

Are you getting Hore in by putting Duursma into the mids?

Was considering this as I have more confidence starting Duursma in the mids vs Butters. Hore can then take Duursma’s starting position in defence. Might move on Butters instead of Setterfield though. Setters DPP might be handy to retain

[Colty]

Is Riley O a must have? I mean it’s free upgrade cash vs trying to get early wins..... discuss

[James Pies]

Hi guys, used to be on this forum a couple of years ago but cant remember my account details. Anyway i had a break from supercoach and decided to start playing again this year. I took a punt on Robbie Gray since he used to always be a good scorer back in the day. Obviously it hasnt really panned out...Should i hold him still? im worried that he is spending way too much time up forward.

[RaisyDaisy]

Feeling good, figured out my trades

Parker and Setters out, ROB and Hore in

Next week Atkins/Scott to Ross and Clark/Burgess to prem forward which will only leave Drew as only fwd rookie on field

Means I need to field Petrucelle this week which sucks, but short term pain for long term gain

Are you getting Hore in by putting Duursma into the mids?

Was considering this as I have more confidence starting Duursma in the mids vs Butters. Hore can then take Duursma’s starting position in defence. Might move on Butters instead of Setterfield though. Setters DPP might be handy to retain

Nah, Duursma stays down back

Setters is in my fwd line so he comes out, Burgess swings fwd, Hore comes in. Leaves me with a solid bench of Clark/Hore

Parker out, Bines fwd, ROB in

Bines/Burgess is fwd bench with Petruccelle F6 which is ugly, but next week I bring in a prem fwd and Pet goes back to bench with Bines

[James Pies]

Feeling good, figured out my trades

Parker and Setters out, ROB and Hore in

Next week Atkins/Scott to Ross and Clark/Burgess to prem forward which will only leave Drew as only fwd rookie on field

Means I need to field Petrucelle this week which sucks, but short term pain for long term gain

Are you getting Hore in by putting Duursma into the mids?

Was considering this as I have more confidence starting Duursma in the mids vs Butters. Hore can then take Duursma’s starting position in defence. Might move on Butters instead of Setterfield though. Setters DPP might be handy to retain

Nah, Duursma stays down back

Setters is in my fwd line so he comes out, Burgess swings fwd, Hore comes in. Leaves me with a solid bench of Clark/Hore

Parker out, Bines fwd, ROB in

Bines/Burgess is fwd bench with Petruccelle F6 which is ugly, but next week I bring in a prem fwd and Pet goes back to bench with Bines

Do you have Heeney?

[SilverLion]

Setters to ROB via Bines, Greene to Worpel for me.

Means fielding Parker (or Petrucelle if he doesn't get up). Forward line definitely my first line I wanna upgrade.

[LaHug]

Setters to ROB via Bines, Greene to Worpel for me.

Means fielding Parker (or Petrucelle if he doesn't get up). Forward line definitely my first line I wanna upgrade.

If you're getting Worpel, wouldn't it be better to just keep Greene? He'll play soon and Worpel's unlikely to be Top 6 I'd have thought. I have Greene still and now that I missed Marshall and Rozee in the last two weeks, I'm not going to throw good money after bad and get someone less good...

[sammy123]

Hi guys, used to be on this forum a couple of years ago but cant remember my account details. Anyway i had a break from supercoach and decided to start playing again this year. I took a punt on Robbie Gray since he used to always be a good scorer back in the day. Obviously it hasnt really panned out...Should i hold him still? im worried that he is spending way too much time up forward.

If you dont have any other issues go for it

[sammy123]

Setters to ROB via Bines, Greene to Worpel for me.

Means fielding Parker (or Petrucelle if he doesn't get up). Forward line definitely my first line I wanna upgrade.

If you're getting Worpel, wouldn't it be better to just keep Greene? He'll play soon and Worpel's unlikely to be Top 6 I'd have thought. I have Greene still and now that I missed Marshall and Rozee in the last two weeks, I'm not going to throw good money after bad and get someone less good...

I know its early but worpel is 10th overall for fwds

[RaisyDaisy]

Setters to ROB via Bines, Greene to Worpel for me.

Means fielding Parker (or Petrucelle if he doesn't get up). Forward line definitely my first line I wanna upgrade.

If you're getting Worpel, wouldn't it be better to just keep Greene? He'll play soon and Worpel's unlikely to be Top 6 I'd have thought. I have Greene still and now that I missed Marshall and Rozee in the last two weeks, I'm not going to throw good money after bad and get someone less good...

I know its early but worpel is 10th overall for fwds

3 of his 4 scores are barely a pass for a prem forward though

I can't see him being Top 10 for the year

[Bully]

Setters to ROB via Bines, Greene to Worpel for me.

Means fielding Parker (or Petrucelle if he doesn't get up). Forward line definitely my first line I wanna upgrade.

If you're getting Worpel, wouldn't it be better to just keep Greene? He'll play soon and Worpel's unlikely to be Top 6 I'd have thought. I have Greene still and now that I missed Marshall and Rozee in the last two weeks, I'm not going to throw good money after bad and get someone less good...

I know its early but worpel is 10th overall for fwds

3 of his 4 scores are barely a pass for a prem forward though

I can't see him being Top 10 for the year

Me neither, he's good for 80-100 but don't think he'll ever rip a game apart. It only takes 1 shocker & then he's stuck in that frustrating range where you feel you are losing points. Much prefer Daniel who would have been my second preference this week.

[Woppa15]

Setters to ROB via Bines, Greene to Worpel for me.

Means fielding Parker (or Petrucelle if he doesn't get up). Forward line definitely my first line I wanna upgrade.

If you're getting Worpel, wouldn't it be better to just keep Greene? He'll play soon and Worpel's unlikely to be Top 6 I'd have thought. I have Greene still and now that I missed Marshall and Rozee in the last two weeks, I'm not going to throw good money after bad and get someone less good...

I know its early but worpel is 10th overall for fwds

3 of his 4 scores are barely a pass for a prem forward though

I can't see him being Top 10 for the year

I also hesitated at Rozee and Marshall for Greene. I’m not considering bringing them in now, the horse has bolted there.
What I am considering is Greene to a Def Rookie (Possibly Hore) via Moore to Fwd. and Mills up to Whitfield.

The outcome being same number of rookies on my field but with team restructured so that 1 less rookie on field Fwd and 1 more rookie on field in Def which I’m comfortable with as Def rookies tend to score better. Another rookie for cash gen plus an underperforming Mills up to an absolute keeper in Whitfield.

Love to hear thoughts, do we think this is a worthy scenario? Only used the one trade so far, currently 29 remaining and ranked inside top 8000.

[Bully]

Setters to ROB via Bines, Greene to Worpel for me.

Means fielding Parker (or Petrucelle if he doesn't get up). Forward line definitely my first line I wanna upgrade.

If you're getting Worpel, wouldn't it be better to just keep Greene? He'll play soon and Worpel's unlikely to be Top 6 I'd have thought. I have Greene still and now that I missed Marshall and Rozee in the last two weeks, I'm not going to throw good money after bad and get someone less good...

I know its early but worpel is 10th overall for fwds

3 of his 4 scores are barely a pass for a prem forward though

I can't see him being Top 10 for the year

I also hesitated at Rozee and Marshall for Greene. I’m not considering bringing them in now, the horse has bolted there.
What I am considering is Greene to a Def Rookie (Possibly Hore) via Moore to Fwd. and Mills up to Whitfield.

The outcome being same number of rookies on my field but with team restructured so that 1 less rookie on field Fwd and 1 more rookie on field in Def which I’m comfortable with as Def rookies tend to score better. Another rookie for cash gen plus an underperforming Mills up to an absolute keeper in Whitfield.

Love to hear thoughts, do we think this is a worthy scenario? Only used the one trade so far, currently 29 remaining and ranked inside top 8000.

First class trading, get it done!